skip navigation

GIRLS' BASKETBALL: Final Two Remain, As Archbishop Carroll and Bonner-Prendergast Remain in the Fight for State Supremacy

By John Knebels, 03/18/19, 11:30PM EDT


By: John Knebels

PIAA PCL Girls’ Basketball Round-Up: The two teams had competed for the Catholic League girls’ championship 19 days earlier, and it necessitated an overtime period to decide the winner.

On Saturday afternoon at Cardinal O’Hara High School, defending league champ Archbishop Carroll and Catholic League runner-up Archbishop Wood met again, this time in a PIAA Class 5A quarterfinal.

PIAA 5A Quarterfinal, Final seconds of Carroll vs. Wood:

While embracing her adorable niece Keke, Harlem Jennings talks about the value of defense:

Mary deSimone describes "being in a zone" with her shooting touch:

Junior Erin Sweeney reflects on the huge win:

Freshman Grace O'Neill said everyone contributed in the victory:

This clash didn’t require any extra sessions. Sparked by an aggressive team defense and some lights-out shooting from senior Mary deSimone, District 12 champ Carroll defeated District 12, three-seed Wood by a misleadingly close 63-48, the third time this season that the Patriots toppled the Vikings.

Carroll will face District 11 top-seed, 26-3 Southern Lehigh 7:30 Tuesday at Souderton High School.

“I knew they were going to be doubling (the other starters) and they were going to leave me open, so I needed to shoot today,” said deSimone. “Beating a team three times is really hard. I knew we needed someone else to step up.”

Whenever Wood (17-12) seemed to make some strides, deSimone answered with a deflating three-pointer. At halftime, the senior guard had already drilled four treys, helping Carroll to a startling 36-22 lead at halftime.

The third quarter was more of the same, as Carroll (24-5) took advantage of Wood foul trouble to consistently shoot free throws. The Patriots ultimately swished 17 of 25 compared to just eight of nine by Wood. 

Although there was a major disparity in fouls, Carroll’s defense was fabulous. Several of the Patriots specifically lauded senior Harlem Jennings for her considerable harassment of Wood’s oft-productive scorers. 

“I was taught that defense wins championships,” said Jennings. “That’s what I have focused on this entire year. It’s a self-awareness thing – knowing what is going on during the game, knowing what you have to do.”

Meanwhile, the Carroll offense increased the lead to 49-30 after three quarters. Behind five three’s, deSimone finished with 16 points. Junior standout Erin Sweeney tallied a game-high 19 and freshman Grace O’Neill deposited 17, including seven of eight from the charity stripe.

“We really had our intensity on defense the whole game,” said Sweeney. “We didn’t have any breakdowns. Whenever they made a shot, I felt like we always had an answer on offense.”

O’Neill said the Patriots respected the Vikings, whose major contributions came from was junior Lindsay Tretter (16 points) and freshman Ryanne Allen (12).

“We were confident coming in,” said O’Neill. “We knew they were a really good team and we needed to play to the best of our abilities. We all contributed together. It was really nice to see that.” 

Meanwhile, Archbishop Prendergast continued its march through the PIAA. The Class 4A District 12 champ Pandas (19-9) overwhelmed District 3, two-seed Bishop McDevitt of Harrisburg, 73-47, setting up a clash with District 11 top-seed Bethlehem Catholic (26-4) 6:00 Tuesday at Souderton High School.  

Junior Dakota McCaughan nailed four threes and finished with a game-high 22 points. Junior Alexis Gleason and senior Maeve McCann added 17 and 16 apiece, respectively. 

“The win was a result of teamwork on both ends of the court,” said McCaughan. “To have everyone contributing makes the game that much more fun. We played for each other.”

The Pandas (19-9) outscored McDevitt (23-5) in every quarter. Leading 36-18 at halftime, Prendergast didn’t allow its foe any momentum moving forward.

MBAP #20 Dakota McCaughan scored 22 points in the Panda's victory vs. Bishop McDevitt (Harrisburg) - PSD Photo by Mike Gray

“The quarterfinal win was very exciting for my coaches, teammates, and I,” said McCann. “It is pumping us all up and getting us very excited to keep competing. We are really coming together as a team and all of our hard work is paying off. We are all working hard for the upcoming game and taking everything one day at a time.”  

This past Friday, Cardinal O’Hara lost to Neshaminy (24-4) 47-35 in the Class 6A quarterfinal.  In the Class 3A, Neumann-Goretti’s season ended with a 54-47 loss to undefeated Dunmore (28-0), the District 2 champion. The District 12 top-seed Saints posted a 20-9 record.


(John Knebels can be reached at or on Twitter @johnknebels.)