skip navigation

GIRLS' BASKETBALL: New Look, Same Winning Attitude as the Catholic League Girls' Squads Return to League Action

By Rich Flanagan - Photos: Geneva Heffernan, Mike Gray, Kathy Leister & Zamani Feelings, 12/18/19, 11:45AM EST

Share

By: Rich Flanagan

Photos/Videos: Geneva Heffernan, Patty Morgan, Angelise Stuhl, Mike Gray, Kathy Leister, Zamani Feelings, Donna Eckert & Alex Duda.

PHILADELPHIA –Maureen Buchter has seen her fair share of Philadelphia Catholic League games in 22 years of coaching. The Little Flower head coach completed her first year at the helm after serving 21 years as an assistant. During that time, she has seen blowouts, ones she has been on the right side of and others she hasn’t, nail biters and overtime gauntlets.

Last season, Little Flower (0-18, 0-12 Philadelphia Catholic League) failed to win a single game. Over the last four years, they’ve only won four league games and building consistency has become more difficult, particularly with having to play the more talented and deeper teams such as Archbishop Carroll, Archbishop Wood, Neumann-Goretti and Cardinal O’Hara. Buchter has been hoping that the league would move to a new format to allow each program a better opportunity to compete and shorten the disparity between them. While last year marked the first time since 2014 that no Philadelphia Catholic League had raised a state title trophy in Hershey, something still needed to be done to improve the league from top to bottom. In the spring, she finally got her wish.

The Philadelphia Catholic League was split into two divisions for girls basketball, as voted on by the league’s athletic directors then approved by the principal of each school. The Sentinels were placed into the Blue Division along with Bishop McDevitt, Conwell-Egan, John W. Hallahan, Lansdale Catholic and St. Hubert’s. The Red Division will feature seven teams, all of which made the league playoffs last year, in the Patriots, Vikings, Saints, Lions, Archbishop Ryan, Bonner-Prendergast and West Catholic.

 Buchter, who also played at Little Flower, feels pleased with the change in format and believes it will have a similar effect as another sport the league split into divisions.

“I’m really excited (athletic director) Adam (Buchter) has pushed for over 20 years to change it and division it like they did in football,” Buchter said. “Girls sports don’t get the attention that the boys gets. It’s disappointing to see but after a vote, it went through and we’re going to be divisions. We’re excited for our girls as they’ll be at a more competitive level with teams that are like us. Definitely talented but not the cream of the crop. It will give our kids a more rewarding sense.”

Little Flower

The Sentinels lost Honorable Mention All-Catholic Alana LaCombe as well as fellow senior Megan Trasser. Buchter will rely on 5-8 senior forward Kelly Bauer, who has been in the rotation since her freshman year and will be “a big force underneath, according to her head coach. Brooklyn Grant, a 5-7 junior forward, “has really come into her own, as Buchter noted and should be a nice complement to Bauer up front. Three seniors in Maura Budd, Natalie O’Neill and Amy Owen should also be key contributors.

The move to a division with comparable teams should help Little Flower establish a building block in Buchter’s second year.

“It can motivate them to realize at their own level they can compete,” Buchter said. “It will be better competition and they’ll be better. There’s more to work and fight for.”

Lansdale Catholic

Lansdale Catholic (16-11, 5-7) fell to Archbishop Carroll in the Philadelphia Catholic League quarterfinals after handling the Lancers. Head coach Eric Gidney’s team wasn’t done yet as they advanced to the second round of the PIAA Class 4A playoffs before falling to District 3’s Bishop McDevitt, 70-31. They lost starting point guard Maile Erwin and Emily Smith. The Crusaders do return Second Team All-Catholic selections junior Timaya Lewis-Eutsey and senior Riley DeVitis. Lewis-Eutsey had 17 points against Jim Thorpe in the state playoffs and 16 vs. Archbishop Wood. DeVitis had 10 points in the contest against the Vikings and 15 vs. West Catholic. Sophomore Lauren Edwards should have a bigger role after showing flashes such as a 16-point game against the Lancers in the regular season.

Conwell-Egan

Chris Brennan begins his third season as the head coach of Conwell-Egan (6-16, 2-10). The Eagles return every player from last year and that should help build some continuity for Brennan’s group.

 “We didn’t lose any players but only gained,” Brennan said. “We had an incredible freshmen class. We’ve added depth and talent. With the Catholic League division changes, it forces us to have a better output from a record standpoint.”

Senior Kiyann Peterson stepped in and had a strong year on her way to Honorable Mention All-Catholic. She had a 16-point game vs. John W. Hallahan and 17 against Harry S. Truman. The 5-3 guard will be one of the top scoring options in the Eagles starting lineup. Kylie Maroney, a 5-8 senior forward, had her season cut short due to a concussion. She only played in 10 of the team’s 22 games. She had 15 points against William Tennent last season and she strengthen Conwell-Egan’s frontcourt. 5-5 senior guard Angel Crowell is the Eagles sole captain. She had a 14-point, seven-bound game vs. Little Flower a year ago. 5-3 junior guard Gia Brennan, Chris’ daughter, “and Kiyaan took on bigger roles in the point department with injuries,” according the head coach. 

Conwell-Egan vs. St. Hubert 2019 Highlights by Alex Duda

Gia had 15 points and eight steals against Tacony Academy Charter then 22 points and five assists in a game vs. the Lancers. Other players to watch are 5-4 senior guard Alyssa Fagans, 5-7 freshman forward Kyliyah Carmichael, Peterson’s sister, and 5-2 freshman guard Katey Brennan, no relation to Chris.

Chris has more options this year than his two previous seasons but he notes it all starts with Peterson.

“We’re hoping to see that maturation and see her take on a leadership role,” Peterson said. “With the Catholic League changes, we really have an opportunity to catapult in terms of a record standpoint. We’re really leaning on her as well as our other seniors.”

Bishop McDevitt

Bishop McDevitt (8-15, 4-8) enters a new era as Dan Greenberg takes over for Steve Prescott. Greenberg began his career as an assistant at Archbishop Wood in the mid-1990s then went to Father Judge where he coached with legendary Crusaders head man Bill Fox for four of his five years there. He has been an assistant on the boys basketball team for several years including last year’s phenomenal run to the Philadelphia Catholic League and PIAA Class 3A semifinals.

Greenberg is hoping to return the Lancers program back to one of the top in the league like it was the late 1980s when head coach Tom Lonergan won four Philadelphia Catholic League titles in 15 years including two led by Cindy Griffin, the Saint Joseph’s women’s head basketball coach and a high school classmate of Greenberg’s.

Lonergan won 500-plus games between his time in Wyncote and Central Bucks East and Greenberg is hoping he can duplicate that success after working under boys coach Will Chavis.

“It came about by surprise,” Greenberg said. “A couple of people had asked me if I was interested and I was happy because the boys program has been doing a lot of good things under Coach Will. I decided it was time to make a change, jump in and help rebuild the program at McDevitt.”

The Lancers advanced to the league playoffs but fell to Lansdale Catholic, 46-43. They rebounded to claim the District 12 Class 2A title and advanced to the PIAA 2A Tournament, where they bowed out to York Catholic in the opening round.

Two accomplished members of that team are gone in Nyah Johnson, now at Roberts Wesleyan College (N.Y.), and Dana Mizelle, an 1,000-point scorer now at East Stroudsburg, both of whom were Honorable Mention All-Catholic's last year.

He’ll look to Amiyah Dixon and Caroline Cunnane, both seniors captains who have been with the program for a few years, and Kate McNally, a volleyball and lacrosse player who Greenberg has helped develop into a key piece this season.

John W. Hallahan

John W. Hallahan (2-15, 1-11) begins year two under Mike Gallagher. Its only win came against Little Flower and another down year added to a streak of 19 consecutive years without a berth in the Philadelphia Catholic League playoffs. They lost Samantha Burns, who was an Honorable Mention All-Catholic in 2017-18 but return junior Ashiah Milburn, an Honorable Mention selection herself, to build around.

St. Hubert

Another program under a second-year head coach is hoping to show improvement. Dave Schafer leads St. Hubert’s (4-18, 3-9) for his second season. The team showed flashes of improved last season including a three-game winning streak following an 0-4 start in league play. He’ll be without Sarah Hartigan, an Honorable Mention All-Catholic who is playing lacrosse at Holy Family after breaking the Bambies all-time scoring record with 160-plus goals. Returning is 5-4 junior Alex May, who had six points against Souderton, 5-8 senior forward Cassidy Ruk and 5-8 junior Payton Pugh, who each had 19 points vs. Little Flower last year.

2019 St. Hubert vs. Little Flower Highlights by Angelise Stuhl

To put into perspective what the Philadelphia Catholic League Red Division boasts, five of the teams have appeared in 11 state championships since 2015, winning six of those. The talent is vast up and down the division and it starts with the defending champion.

Archbishop Carroll

Renie Shields had witnessed what it was like to win a Philadelphia Catholic League championship as an assistant being a member of three titles under Chuck Creighton but winning her first as a head coach was a defining moment for her and the program. Archbishop Carroll (25-6, 11-1) hung on to down Archbishop Wood, 48-42 in overtime to claim its first league title since 2012. From there, the Patriots kept on rolling, including another win over the Vikings, all the way to the PIAA Class 5A title game where they were upended by Chartiers Valley, 53-40. It was the program’s first trip to a state title game in seven years, just like the league title.

Shields knew last year’s corps was selection and she witnessed each player do their part to help the team succeed.

“The best thing about that group was that every player accepted their role, defended every possession and really stayed within themselves,” Shields said. “We had preached to them all year to do what they were capable of doing."

The Patriots will be without Harlem Jennings (USciences), who had 15 points in the league title game, and Mary DeSimone (West Chester).

Drexel commit Erin Sweeney, a 5-10 senior forward, is back after averaging 18.4 points per game on her way to being named First Team All-Catholic. She had 37 points in a game against West Catholic and 19 in the state title game. She also surpassed the 1,000-point mark for her career in the second round of the PIAA 5A playoffs vs. Gettysburg.

She’ll be joined by 5-4 sophomore guard Grace O’Neill, who had 13 points and converted the go-ahead basket with 1:28 remaining in OT of the Philadelphia Catholic League title game. The Second Team All-Catholic selection, who Shields said has a “willingness to step on the court and a presence. She now better understands what we’re asking her to do and how to be more vocal as a point guard,” had 15 points against the Vikings in the state quarterfinals. 

Hope Syron, 5-11 senior forward, returns as well as 5-7 junior guard Karli Dougherty, who hit a game-tying three-pointer and the go-ahead basket to down Cardinal O’Hara last season. She also had six points in that PIAA 5A title game. One new addition is junior Maggie Grant, a transfer from Bishop Shanahan, who was an Honorable Mention All-Ches-Mont League and had five points against West Chester Henderson in the District 1 Class 5A quarterfinals.

Archbishop Carroll senior Erin Sweeney scored her 1,000th career point in last years PIAA 5A state playoff game vs. Gettysburg:

2019 Catholic League Championship Highlights by Angelise Stuhl:

Archbishop Wood

Head coach Mike McDonald and Archbishop Wood (17-12, 9-3), who have won five state titles since 2011, fell twice at the hands of the Patriots in the biggest games of the year but the Vikings return a vaunted lineup that is hoping to claim the program’s first league title in four years. Gone is a quarter of integral seniors in Annie Whalen (Kutztown), Ryleigh Parsons (Jefferson), Elizabeth Fasti (Misericordia University) and Mia Andrews (University of Charleston).

McDonald has several options to replace what the Class of 2019 did. It starts with 5-8 senior guard and Holy Family commit Lindsay Tretter and 5-8 junior guard Noelle Baxter, who had eight points against Archbishop Carroll in the state playoffs. The player who should make the biggest jump is 6-0 sophomore guard Ryanne Allen. Allen was an Honorable Mention All-Catholic and already has offers from La Salle, Drexel, St. Joe’s and Rider while Boston College and Penn State are also showing interest. She had 11 points against Cardinal O’Hara in the Philadelphia Catholic League playoffs and 12 vs. the Patriots in the PIAA 4A quarterfinals.

A big addition is 6-1 senior and Northeastern commit Izzy Larsen. A transfer from Wesleyan (Ga.) where she helped her team win two Georgia High School Association A Private titles. Larsen, who had 16 points in the state quarterfinals a year ago, “makes us a lot tougher. She gives us a post-up presence and can play with her back to the basketball. She can give us an inside-outside presence,” according to McDonald.

Still, the mainstay and focal point of the offense is 5-10 junior guard and two-time First Team All-Catholic selection Kaitlyn Orihel. She avg. 17.1 ppg last season which included a career-high 31 points (16 in the fourt quarter) and league postseason record 19-for-20 from the free-throw in the semifinals against Neumann-Goretti.

 Orihel has already established herself as a dominant scorer and an elite player in the Philadelphia Catholic League but McDonald feels she could be poised for her best season yet with the amount of talent around her.

“With the additions that we have and the growth that we’ve experienced, her IQ has increased and she’s facilitating a lot more,” McDonald said. “I think her having that ability and that confidence in her teammates is going to open things up for them. I thought last year she forced a lot but she’s so talented she was able to score.”

Neumann-Goretti

All Diamond Johnson has done at Neumann-Goretti (20-9, 11-1) is score, facilitate and take over a game. The 5-6 senior guard and Rutgers commit was the 2019 Gatorade Pa. Player of the Year and Pa. All-State Girls Class 3A Player of the Year avg. 25.8 ppg. She joins Jabria Ingram (Hartford), Chyna Nixon, Alisha Kebbe (St. John’s) & Ciani Cryor as the fifth straight Saints player to win 3A POY honors. She posted a school-record 54 points against Imhotep Charter to claim the PIAA District 12 Class 3A Title. As if the national and statewide accolades weren’t enough, she also Philadelphia Catholic League MVP, the 4th straight MVP from Neumann-Goretti, joining Kebbe, Nixon and Ingram.

Sixth-year head coach Andrea Peterson has Johnson evolve in someone who can carry a team by themselves.

“She’s our leader and only senior,” Peterson said. “She makes it a lot easier for a coach when you have a point guard who sees the floor, can make decisions, sees matchup issues and can single handedly take over a game herself.”

Peterson has had success as both a coach with four state titles and as a player. She won two league crowns with Archbishop Carroll in 2003 and 2004 while also being a two-time First Team All-Catholic. She was also the starting point guard for Drexel, where she led the Dragons to the 2009 Colonial Athletic Association championship and the NCAA Tournament for the first time in program history.

The Saints fell to Wood, 60-50 in the league quarterfinals but they did something in the state playoffs that they hadn’t done in over four years: lose. Their run of four straight PIAA Class 3A titles came to an end in the quarterfinals at the hands of Dunmore.

Compared to years past, Peterson’s team is not a defending state champion and the road to getting back to be mentioned as one of the best programs in the state starts with preparation for the Philadelphia Catholic League.

“I think our kids have built that every year they’re going to get there,” Peterson said. “Dunmore did a very good job and they played very well. One thing we take from that game is we can learn. When your best players aren’t playing well, other players need to step up and take that role. That’s something we’re taking on this year.”

The Saints will be without Kiara Kroger, a First Team All-Catholic now at Holy Family, and Second Team All-Catholic Nia Jordan, playing at the University of New Orleans.

Joining Johnson will be 5-7 junior guard Jonelle Price, who “saw minutes last year and has really matured tremendously,” according to Peterson. She had seven points against Warrior Run in the PIAA 3A second round. Omoiye Jordan, a 5-8 junior, is the best shooter on the Neumann-Goretti roster and Prunelle Mungo, a 6-2 junior forward, will be an option in the frontcourt.

Cardinal O’Hara

Chrissy Doogan begins her second season overseeing Cardinal O’Hara (15-12, 8-4). The two-time Philadelphia Catholic League MVP took over for storied coach Linus McGinty last season. In Doogan’s first season, the Lions fell to Archbishop Wood in the league quarterfinals, failing to advance to the title game for the first time since 2016. They bounced back to win the District 12 Class 6A title, their 10th straight district crown, over Central, 76-29. They made a run to the PIAA 6A quarterfinals before falling to Neshaminy. The only key player lost from last season was Kerry Patterson, a two-year starter playing at USciences.

Doogan returns a young roster and it starts with sophomore Sydni Scott, the only freshman named First Team All-Catholic last year. She had 17 points in a game against Conwell-Egan and 11 vs. Spring-Ford in the second round of the PIAA 6A Tournament. Sophomore Maggie Doogan, Chrissy’s daughter, had 11 points in the opening round of the state playoffs against Plymouth-Whitemarsh and should only expand her role in year two. Sophomore Siobhan Boylan had nine points vs. the Vikings in the league quarterfinals and will be one of the Lions options down low.

On Thurs. Dec. 12, 2019 Neumann-Goretti kicked off PCL play with a 74-70 victory vs. Cardinal O'Hara - Highlights by Geneva Heffernan:

Bonner-Prendergast

Bonner-Prendergast (19-10, 8-4) has advanced to the PIAA Class 4A semifinals in each of the last two seasons. They fell to eventual champion, Bethlehem Catholic, 64-50 to put an end to last year’s run. 

Additionally, they also fell to another champion, Archbishop Carroll in the league semifinals a month prior to that. Head coach Tom Stewart, in his 27th season at the helm of the Pandas, must replace Maeve McCann, who avg. 11.5 ppg and is now playing at Jefferson University, Ariana McGeary (Cabrini  University) and Dakota McCaughan, who transferred to Ridley High School for her final season. McCaughan had 22 points against Bishop McDevitt (District 3) in the state quarterfinals.

The Pandas are hoping to make another run in the state playoffs but also return to the Palestra. Senior Alexis Gleason (West Chester) returns for her third year as a starter. 

On Fri. Dec. 13, Prendie opened its season suffering a tough 47-36 loss on the road vs. Carroll - Highlights by James Williamson:

Juniors Alexis Eagan and Regan Dolan will be key contributors and sophomore guard Bridie McCann, Maeve’s sister who has seven points in the state quarterfinals, will have an expanded role this season.

West Catholic

Two years ago, West Catholic (15-8, 9-3) was one win from walking away with the PIAA Class 2A title. Last year, after succumbing to Bonner-Prendergast in the Philadelphia Catholic League quarterfinals, the Burrs looked poised for another deep run but feel to St. Basil Academy, 70-49 in the opening round of the 2A playoffs. Beulah Osueke, entering her seventh season as head coach of West Catholic, will have to replace two starters from last year in Kyliah Singletary, who is playing at Holy Family and was a starter of the state title game team, and Amiyah Edney-Holmes, a Second Team All-Catholic last season now playing at the Community College of Baltimore County Essex.

The Burrs have become a program that consistently makes the league playoffs and has become a regular in the state playoffs under Osueke. She has developed a way to prepare her team for each part of the season including a potential trip to multiple postseasons.

“The number one thing I’ve learned as a coach is pacing,” Osueke said. “In my first three or four years, I think I was trying to make us respectful. I wanted us to respect each other, develop talent and challenge them. After a while, the regular season come postseason time felt like preseason. I always say we have three separate seasons: regular, the Catholic League tournament and the state tournament. I try to space it out and not harp on everything right away.”

Destiney McPhaul, a 5-8 junior guard and a First Team All-Catholic, will be a go-to option for the Burrs. She was a Second Team All-Catholic as a freshman when West Catholic advanced to the state title game.

McPhaul, who has offers from Virginia Tech, Temple, Rhode Island and St. Joe’s, had a 14-point, 11-rebound performance in the league quarterfinals. Daizy Wilson, a 5-5 junior guard who was the team’s sharpshooter a season ago, had 19 points against St. Basil Academy. Junior guard Ciani Montgomery was a Second Team All-Catholic and had 11 points in a loss to Archbishop Wood. Montgomery has some talent in her family as Diamond Johnson’s cousin and “she has a lot of potential and she doesn’t how good she is,” according to Osueke.

Two players who suffered season-ending injuries in the same game will also return to the rotation. 5-6 point guard Tamiah Robinson tore her ACL and missed the final week of December through the rest of the season. She avg. 13.9 ppg and was a Pa. All-State Class 3A Second Team pick as a sophomore. Safara McIntyre, a 5-10 junior forward, was also injured in that same game and missed the remainder of the year. Both are back and ready to contribute in a big way.

Archbishop Ryan

While Archbishop Ryan (12-10, 7-5) was the only Red Division team not to make the state playoffs last year, Mike McCusker’s team will have to replace one of the most accomplished players in program history. Monee Moore, who McCusker emphasized, “you can’t replace people with her,” was a three-time First Team All-Catholic now playing at Holy Family. She scored 1,003 career points, becoming only the third player in Ragdolls history to score 1,000 joining Jen Snell, who played at Villanova, and Jess Koci, who led Archbishop Ryan to the PIAA 4A title game in 2010 and played at La Salle. Another missing piece will Shayne Glenn (Delaware Valley), who was a Second Team All-Catholic last year.

The Raiders fell to Neumann-Goretti, 67-61 in the Philadelphia Catholic League quarterfinals. Without Moore and Glenn, the roster is fairly young as there will be only three upperclassmen on the 11-player roster. Tori Nigro was a Second Team All-Catholic as a freshman. The 5-4 point guard had 14 points in a game against Bonner-Prendergast.

 McCusker will look to her to not only run the offense but take it upon herself to score a lot more than her first season.

“We inserted her right away,” McCusker said. “She has very good knowledge of the game and she’s a terrific point guard. Teams will be a little more focused on her because she’s a returning All-Catholic and we lost two, great scorers. She’s got a lot more on her plate this year.”

She’ll be joined by seniors Gabi Deluisi and Cait Geiger, who was a starter last season, as well as junior Luca Verello.

McCusker knows he has a lot to replace and knows there will not be any nights off playing in a loaded division.

“We’re playing a Division 1 player on every Catholic League team, if not more than that,” McCusker said. “It’s going to be a rough schedule. We’ve ramped up the schedule to challenge and play the best. It’s going to be a grind.”

The league will not have any crossover play between the divisions during the regular season. Each team will play each other twice within its division. This will allow teams to schedule more games against talent from around the area with more nonleague games available. The league will decide after the season to continue with the division breakdown or return to a single division, where everyone plays each other once. Moving to divisions is a concept being appreciated by most, especially Buchter, and it looks to be a benefit to all members of the league.