skip navigation

GIRLS BASKETBALL: Every Game Counts, As Philadelphia Catholic League Teams Return to Hardwood Action

By John Knebels Photos/Videos: Kathy Leister, Donna Eckert & Angelise Stuhl , 01/28/21, 1:15PM EST

Share

By: John Knebels

Photos/Videos: Donna Eckert, Kathy Leister, Patty Morgan, Mike Nance & Angelise Stuhl

PHILADELPHIA –The time has finally come when the constant chatter of disturbing pandemic updates will be somewhat softened by the echoes of basketballs pounding hardwood floors.

Now, exactly when and from where those dribbles will reverberate is anybody’s guess. Because of coronavirus-related uncertainties, every currently scheduled game comes with an asterisk, and the word “pending” has become an integral inclusion in the 2021 scholastic lexicon.  

Although Philadelphia Catholic League girls’ administrators, coaches, players, and families have been bombarded by seemingly daily alterations, a winter plan has been devised. 

There will again be two divisions – a Red and a Blue. Games are scheduled to begin on January 29 and continue into early March, with each team playing each of the other division squads twice. Unlike the traditional playoff system that included qualifiers, quarterfinals, semifinals, and finals, the Catholic League postseason will only consist of a championship final between the first- and second-place teams from the Red Division. 

Meanwhile, the Pennsylvania Interscholastic Athletic Association (PIAA) anticipates tournament competition, albeit with fewer teams. The District 12 representatives – only one from each class – will be determined by how they fare in Catholic League play.

Since they are the defending Catholic League champions, West Catholic (8-4 regular season; third place before running the table) will – like it or not – carry the moniker of being “the favorite” despite competing against several excellent teams that return significant experience after making plentiful noise in last year’s postseason – both in the Catholic League and the PIAA tournament.

The Lady Burrs carry an 11-game winning streak into the season. It may have been longer, but their season was cut short in the PIAA quarterfinals because of the coronavirus. No longer an underdog and definitely the team wearing the proverbial bulls eye, the Lady Burrs appear quite capable of a repeat.

2020 Philadelphia Catholic League Championship Highlights - West Catholic vs. Arch. Wood by Angelise Stuhl:

Virginia Tech commit senior Destiney McPhaul made first-team all-state last year after a superb season punctuated by a 30-point explosion in a 65-60 overtime Catholic League championship victory over Archbishop Wood. She is joined by standouts Ciani Montgomery – an All-Catholic who scored 16 in the PCL final and has committed to Lincoln University – Daziy Montgomery-Wilson, and senior Ti Eisha Walker.

Beulah Osueke, last year’s Class 3A coach of the year, will join other city coaches who have had countless practice opportunities nullified by COVID-19 precautions. But Osueke can’t do anything about that, so she is challenging her players to deal with reality and make the most of it.

“With this year's format, every game counts,” said Osueke. “No one can afford to overlook anyone. The season doesn't allow for any slumps. We can enter every practice and game with the knowledge that any lapse in focus or intensity will affect our hopes of post-season play. Knowing this, we're forced to be sharp and intentional with our time and energy on all fronts. It's been helpful for our leadership and team chemistry.”

Anticipating each game to be “highly intense,” Osueke expects every opponent to leave nothing on the court.


This year the Lady Burrs will be lead by senior Virginia Tech commit, Destiney McPhaul - PSD Photo by Mike Nance

"I'm excited for my kids to just play,” said Osueke. “We've been waiting to return back to basketball for nearly 10 months. It's difficult to see just how much the community we share with each other means until it's completely taken from you. We're appreciative of an opportunity to play; we don't plan to take a single game for granted.”

Archbishop Wood (Red Division champion after an 11-1 record) returns eight players with significant game experience from a season that included the aforementioned overtime loss in the Catholic League championship and a trip to the PIAA state quarterfinals before the tournament was cancelled.

A startling five players have been offered Division I scholarships. Leading the pack is Kaitlyn Orihel. The Villanova University-bound, Class 5A Player of the Year senior has already eclipsed 1,000 career points. Joining Orihel is all-state junior sharpshooter Ryanne Allen, senior guard and Kutztown College commit Noelle Baxter, junior guard Bri Bowen, senior tri-captain and Bryant College commit Dana Kiefer, junior guard Shannon Morgan, sophomore guard Delaney Finnegan, and sophomore guard Allie Fleming

“Every game is definitely like a playoff game,” said Wood coach Mike McDonald. “Only having two teams make it out of the regular season in our league leaves little room for losing. We also never know when something out of our control could shut us down. The kids, especially seniors, need to really cherish each game they get to play and give their max on every play.”


Senior Villanova commit Kaitlyn Orihel, will continue to display her leadership for the Vikings this year - PSD Photo by Mike Nance.

Archbishop Carroll (5-7; fifth place; lost 50-47 quarterfinal heartbreaker to Cardinal O’Hara in overtime), whose state title run was also stopped by COVID in the quarterfinals, returns three starters. First-team All-Catholic junior guard Grace O’Neill is a two-year starter and ferocious hustler. Senior Karli Dougherty is a strong defender, rebounder, and overall steady presence on offense. Junior guard Maggie Grant provides strong outside shooting.

“For us, the main focus is on playing together offensively and defensively,” said Carroll coach Renie Shields. “We have to trust one another, be patient, and be engaged . . . and stay healthy.”

With four starters and three more key reserves returning, Cardinal O’Hara (7-5; fourth place; lost to Archbishop Wood in semifinals) will look almost identical to last year.

All-Catholic seniors Amaris Baker and Siobhan Boylan have already chosen their Division I college destinations at Kennesaw State and Marist College, respectively. Juniors Sydni Scott (first-team All-Catholic and third-team all-state) and All-Catholic Maggie Doogan have also received Division I interest. Junior Annie Welde joins seniors Julia Stellebotte and Kaitlin McPeak to form a mega-strong top seven. 


Archbishop Carroll junior Grace O'Neill and Cardinal O'Hara junior Sydni Scott fight for a loose ball. Both will be key contributors this season - PSD Photo by Mike Nance

“I don’t see any major advantages or disadvantages with a shortened season,” said coach Chrissie Doogan. “Most teams return their core players, so they should be able to jump in and continue where they left off last year.”

Trivia alert: Freshman guard Joanie Quinn expects to earn valuable minutes. Quinn’s mother, Joanie Gallagher, was the starter on O’Hara’s 1991 Catholic League championship squad. Her teammate? O’Hara coach Chrissie Doogan.

At Neumann-Goretti (9-3; second place; lost to West Catholic in semifinals), seniors Sierra Bermudez (All-Catholic), Omoiye JordanChrista RicksJonelle Price, junior point guard Mahjae Hayes (All-Catholic), and sophomore Cameron Graham will try to elevate the Saints to their first Catholic League title in six years. 

“We have some really good talent coming back,” said coach Andrea Peterson. “We can’t control what’s happening right now with the pandemic. We just have to take it day by day and enjoy any opportunity we are giving to play games.

“The city schools are at a disadvantage with all this right now. Practice times are limited, and having no contact is tough. Through all this, I’m proud of our girls and the way they continue to push through every obstacle we have been faced with. 


Neumann-Goretti senior, Sierra Bermudez will be one of the Saint's players to watch this season - PSD Photo by Patty Morgan.

“Every game will feel like it’s the playoffs because we are all fighting for the top two spots. They will be hard fought games throughout.”

At Bonner-Prendergast (2-10; sixth place; lost to West Catholic in quarterfinals), four returning starters – junior All-Catholic Bridie McCann (averaged 12 points and four assists), senior Alexis Eagan (leading three-point shooter), senior Reagan Dolan, and junior Emma Beaty – highlight a team that also advanced to the PIAA quarterfinals before COVID shenanigans. 

Junior Aniyah Jackson started half the season before becoming the first option off the bench. Junior Meghan Kilroy and freshman Keira Henrich look poised to contribute.  

The Pandas lost two weeks of practice time because the school was being quarantined because of COVID. 

“Every game will be like the playoffs,” said B-P coach Tom Stewart. “Our league is extremely talented this year, maybe the best I've seen in years. I think four of those teams could win state titles if we get that far.

“We will be very competitive. We did win our first two games in states last season, so my kids know what it takes to win. It's funny. After coaching for 51 years, I still get excited, especially in practice.”

Last season, Bonner-Prendergast secured a 52-46 overtime victory vs. Eastern York, advancing to the PIAA quarterfinals

After thoroughly dominating the Blue Division, Lansdale Catholic was overwhelmed by Archbishop Wood in the quarterfinals. Their “gift” for a perfect 10-0 regular season was being moved to the Red Division.

Coached by Eric Gidney, the Crusaders return second-team All-Catholic Lauren Edwards and second-team All-Catholic sophomore Gabby Casey.

Blue Division Blues – No Chance at a PCL Title

Although the Blue Division won’t have an opportunity to collect a championship plaque, two of the six schools will be followed more for sentimentality than drama. 

John W. Hallahan and Bishop McDevitt will be playing their final seasons. The archdiocese of Philadelphia announced early in the academic year that both schools would close in June.


Hallahan point guard Ashiah Milburn, guarded by Little Flowers Kelly Bauer '20, will continue to lead the Mickey Mouse their final season - PSD Photo by Geneva Heffernan

Despite protests, fundraising and imploration, the archdiocese remained firm in its decision, leaving current students and graduates angry, dismayed, bitter, and confused. 

“These girls in our program love McDevitt and love playing basketball for their school, and to have it ripped away from them is a shame,” said McDevitt coach Dan Greenberg, a 1988 McDevitt alum. “Lady Lancer Basketball has a storied history in the Philadelphia Catholic League, and we plan to honor all past players and coaches by working hard each practice and game.”

Hallahan coach Mike Gallagher echoed his coaching adversary-turned-advocate. 

“As a team, we have the opportunity to write the ending to our program,” said Gallagher. “We are committed to fulfilling that opportunity to have a season we can be proud of.”

When the two teams meet on February 2 (at Hallahan) and February 19 (at McDevitt), Hallahan (2-8; fifth place; lost to Archbishop Carroll in first round) will rely on two-time All-Catholic point guard Ashiah Milburn and junior forward Mya Sulimay

“With a short season, it's more important to get off to a good start,” said Gallagher. “We don't have a lot of time to find our stride. I imagine there will be some ugly games early on, and the winners will be the teams that make the least amount of mistakes. Fundamentals take on an outsized importance relative to other years.”

Meanwhile, McDevitt sports three returning starters in senior All-Catholic Sianni Posey, senior Kate McNally, and junior Kelly Roache. Also back are senior Morgan Harris, junior Messiah White, and junior Emma Obfenda.  

Greenberg echoed many other coaches regarding his major concerns.


Bishop McDevitt junior Kelly Roache will help lead the Lady Lancers in their final season - PSD Photo by Kathy Leister.

“The lack of practice time before the season will put all teams at a disadvantage,” said Greenberg. “Conditioning will be a factor, but I assume all teams will be in the same boat. 

“One fear for the shortened season would be bad weather, which could really wreak havoc on our schedules.”  


Ryan senior Luca Verello (#14) returns as a stable piece in a young Ragdoll squad - PSD Photo by Donna Eckert.

Archbishop Ryan (0-12; seventh place in Red Division; lost to Neumann-Goretti in quarterfinals), which last year played in the Red Division, was gutted by graduation more than most teams.

New Ragdolls coach and 1978 Ryan alum Chris Zambito will attempt to mold numerous youngsters (including several freshmen) around two steady foundational pieces – senior Luca Verello and junior Mackenzie Reed

“We’re very inexperienced,” said Zambito. “Luca and Mackenzie have both shown great leadership to our younger players. They both are working extremely hard at practices.”

While lamenting the disappointment for seniors who will be playing their last scholastic season of hoops during a pandemic, Zambito said “every team has to prepare the same, so the length of the season isn't an advantage or disadvantage.”

At St. Hubert (8-2; second place; lost to Lansdale Catholic in first round), coach Dave Schafer lost only one starter. While adding talented junior swing Gianna Grassifulli, a transfer from Archbishop Ryan, returnees include a trio of All-Catholics in senior forward Payton Pugh, sophomore guard Mia Tobin, and sophomore guard Mackenzie McLaughlin.

Add to the mix senior torward Sarah Spaeth, sophomore forward Kate Patterson, junior forward Charlotte Pugh, senior guard Emma McNamee, and senior guard Alexa May.

“The shortened season is a disadvantage, especially for the city schools because of the restrictions placed upon us by the city,” said Schafer. “There is not enough time to get everything in and up to game preparation. No non-league schedule is a definite minus.

“This is our third year with the program, and we feel that we are getting better each season. Our girls have really committed themselves to a great work ethic, a real sense of team unity, and great pride in the program. Each player has come back a better player, and this only makes St. Hubert better. I can't say enough about our kids’ devotion and loyalty.”


St. Hubert sophomore Mackenzie McLaughlin, made the All-Catholic third team as a freshman - PSD Photo by Kathy Leister

At Conwell-Egan (6-4; third place; lost to Archbishop Ryan in first round), returnees Kyliyah Carmichael (sophomore first-team All-Catholic), Gia Brennan (senior All-Catholic), senior Isabel Foy, and sophomore Katey Brennan form a strong nucleus.

“The shortened season, coupled with a significant youth movement, would seem to limit our ability to gel as a team, but this group of young women have exceeded expectations,” said Eagles coach Chris Brennan. “The chemistry is currently in mid-season form, and we are optimistic that it will transfer when the season starts.  

“Ideally, the younger players benefit greatly with a full schedule. We challenged the ladies to be accountable for competitive practices every session and they responded with some of the best sessions in our four years heading up the program.


Conwell-Egan sophomore guard Kyliyah Carmichael returns as a young starter for the Lady Eagles - PSD Photo by Kathy Leister

“The school and the girls’ basketball program was truly blessed with an incoming freshman class that infuses a very encouraging amount of athleticism and talent. This class has already made a very significant impact on the program by raising the bar in workouts. Optimism is high and the future is bright. We are looking forward to seeing how it translates when we tip off really soon.”

At Little Flower (4-6; fourth place; lost to Bonner-Prendergast in first round), coach Maureen Buchter made a particular shout out to a strong graduating class.

“We lost five seniors often referred to by me as ‘The Fab Five,’” said Buchter. “Although difficult to lose their guidance and experience, ‘The Fab Five’ led by example, which will prepare the returning players to step up to this challenge during this difficult and unprecedented time.”

The Sentinels return three seniors in All-Catholic Mikyla GrantHailey Bickel, and Brianna Seedes. Buchter lauded the trio for their leadership and determination. Sophomore point-guard Gabrielle Dever and freshman forward Kaidence McCormac are players to watch.


Sophomore starting point guard, Gabby Dever, will bring added energy for the Sentinels this year - PSD Photo by Kathy Leister.

“Gabby was thrown into the fire last season as a freshman and exceeded my expectations,” said Buchter. “Gabby will again run the point, and there is no doubt in my mind that she will continue where she left off.  There are those that are passionate about basketball, and then there is ‘Gabby's passion’ for basketball.  

“The new freshmen coming in have shown talent and a love for the game of basketball. I look forward to watching them grow and develop over the next four years both on the court and off.”

Buchter waxed philosophical about playing hoops during a pandemic.

“My advice to my team now and throughout the season will be a focus on ‘safety first,’ and if given the opportunity to compete, take that gift and play the game that you love,” she said. “I will encourage the team to dream big during this unprecedented time. 

“The team will be reminded throughout this short season that this difficult time in their lives is intended to make them better basketball players, but more importantly, better individuals in their journey through life.”

   

(Contact John Knebels at Jknebels@gmail.com or on Twitter @johnknebels).