skip navigation

PCL Boys Round-Up: Baseball, Lacrosse and Volleyball Spring into Action

By John Knebels, 04/17/22, 1:00AM EDT

Share

Photos/Videos: Zack Beavers, Tommy Muir, Kathy Leister, Mike Nance, Ryan Nix, Lennie Malmgren, James Williamson, Mark Zimmaro & John Knebels

By: John Knebels

PHILADELPHIA – Starting in December and finishing in late March, winter sports seem to go on forever. Then spring competition hits, and in about six weeks, it’s time for the postseason.

So with no time to waste, let’s get to a Philadelphia Catholic League roundup.

In PCL baseball, the ascent of Archbishop Carroll continues to soar. The Patriots started 0-3 last season but finished with three wins in its last four games. That trend has continued.

Now at 3-0 after victories over Father Judge, St. Joseph’s Prep, and Cardinal O’Hara, the Patriots have ridden the bats of junior James Brown (.444 average, 1.075 OPS), senior Sam Benvignati (.333, 1.009), and junior Zach Stearns (.444, 1.212, 10 runs scored) while befuddling the opposition via senior pitcher Roman Tozzi (1.59 earned-run average in 22 innings pitched).

In the win over O’Hara, Tozzi fired a five-hit, one-walk, complete-game shutout. Against Father Judge, he allowed four hits and two runs and whiffed nine over six innings while senior Harold Ivery and Benvignati notched two RBI apiece. He didn’t pitch against the Prep, but the Patriots hiked a three-run triple by Benvignati to ignite a five-run sixth inning and earn a 7-5 comeback win.

Not a bad start for first-year Carroll coach Jonathan Grosse.

“Anytime you win in this league, it’s big,” said the New York native who played college ball at Kutztown University. “It’s the best league in the state. It’s super exciting for our players and program.

“This group of guys have been completely bought in since we started in the fall. They’re a special group. I’m excited to watch them compete the rest of the year.”

Archbishop Carroll vs. Cardinal O'Hara - PSD Highlights by Lennie Malmgren

Grosse was particularly impressed with the win over the Prep.

“Great team win,” said Grosse. “Prep jumped out to a lead. Evan Wineburg (senior) did a phenomenal job in relief giving us zeros. Offense did a really good job with a pretty good arm for them. Got to their bullpen and we took our shot. Chris Tomlinson was awesome with the glove playing shortstop.”

To label Tomlinson, a senior, excited about playing defense is putting it mildly.

“Our defense is what we know we can count on,” he said. “Sometimes we’ll be coming up against a stud pitcher or someone that we’re going to have to work for every base we can get and every run, but all of our pitchers know that they don’t need a strikeout to get out of a pinch. We all trust each other and we know how to play together.

“That feeling when someone tells you that your team looks sharp defensively is almost unmatched. Winning is one thing, but we’ve been playing at an elite level in the infield and outfield, and that makes everything easier on our pitchers and on our batting lineup.”

*****

Neumann-Goretti needed a signature victory.

The Saints nabbed one.

With sophomore Jayce Park going the distance and allowing only one run and two walks while striking out seven, N-G defeated La Salle, 6-1, and improved to 3-0. Senior Joe Brasky knocked in a pair of runs.

Toppling the defending champion Explorers on the road supplied more juice to N-G’s on-field celebration.

“It was definitely most exciting beating them at their place,” said senior Jameson Masino, who dealt a single and run scored. “They are a great team every year, and it definitely felt good having a lead from the start of the game.

“It is a huge difference beating them at their place on the road, but we didn’t lose any of our energy the entire game. We had the momentum from the first pitch and didn’t let it go. Today was a great day for the team.”

Neumann-Goretti senior Salvatore Laimo said everyday is a battle in the PCL - Video by Mark Zimmaro

Neumann-Goretti senior Jayce Park talks about his strategy on the mound - PSD Video by Mark Zimmaro

*****

Nine days earlier, Archbishop Wood also managed a win at La Salle, though this one included several twists and turns.

Trailing 5-3, the Vikings plated six runs in the sixth and collected a 10-6 victory to partially avenge their heartbreaking 3-2, eight-inning loss to La Salle in last year’s PCL championship.

Senior Mike Trommer ignited the comeback with a three-run blast. Teammates Braden Kelly (sophomore) and Pat McKinney (senior)  added two RBI each. Senior Connor Woodson earned the win in relief.

“The homerun felt great, especially in the situation and the game,” said Trommer, a Bucknell University commit. “It definitely feels different, especially after they beat us twice last year, and that it was so late in the game. It was a huge momentum swing for us and got us going.”

Wood coach Jim DiGuiseppe, Jr. also maintained an even keel.

"It was a solid opening season win on the road,” he said. “I was proud of our players’ resilience."

Wood vs. La Salle - PSD Game Highlights by Kathy Leister

The Vikings have not stopped winning ever since.

A 14-4 win over Archbishop Ryan included an epic performance by junior Dan Tiburcio, who went 4-for-4 with five RBI, a homer, and two runs scored. A 4-0 victory at Cardinal O’Hara was highlighted by senior Justin MacCain’s near no-hitter. The senior went six innings and only surrendered two walks, but his pitch count reached 102, so he had to be lifted by league rules. Trommer aided the offense by belting a homer.

In yesterday’s 8-3 triumph over the Prep, Trommer allowed no earned runs and struck out 10.  McKinney drilled a home run and a double and knocked in three. Senior Sean Slowinski added two RBI.  

“In the first at bat I got to two strikes really quickly, so I was just looking to get my foot down early and put the ball in play,” said McKinney. “Later in the game when I hit the double, it made think of a game last year where I was in almost the same situation, and I’ve wanted a moment just like that to come up again.”

*****

Father judge junior Liam Newhouse’s single in the bottom of the seventh lifted the Crusaders past St. Joseph’s Prep, 3-2. Now at 2-1, Judge is one of five PCL teams with a winning record entering the break.

Trailing 2-1, junior Sean Moore led off the seventh with a seven-pitch walk. Junior Nick Shiffler followed with a single to left. A wild pitch advanced runners to second and third, and a single by junior Ryan Biener tied the game at 2-2.

After an intentional walk loaded the bases. On a 1-1 pitch, Newhouse roped a single to right field to score Shiffler.

Game over.  

“Knowing that the game was tied and we had bases loaded, I just had to hit the ball,” said Newhouse. “All I remember is hitting the ball and then all my friends celebrating with me.”

Judge coach Mike Metzger has been particularly inspired by the Crusaders’ pitching staff.

“I love our pitching staff this year,” he said, specifying the work of senior John Westfield, sophomore David Rodriguez, and sophomore Tim Gress. “They will give us a chance to win every day.” 

Father Judge vs. Carroll - PSD Highlights by Lennie Malmgren

*****

Scoring a run against Bonner-Prendergast is not an easy task. Getting the Friars to make three outs isn’t exactly simple, either.

Enveloping the Friars’ 4-0 record is a run differential of 38-4, with three shutouts. Among the scorchers are sophomore Irvin Fisher (.455 average, 1.571 OPS), Kevin McGonigle (.538, 1.838, 2 homers, 6 RBI), Mike Anderson (.462, 1.303), Joey DeMucci (.400, 1.167), James Sousa (.364, .825), and sophomore Harry Carr (.333, .887).

B-P’s league opener, an 8-0 win over visiting Roman Catholic, was highlighted by Fisher’s outstanding two-out catch with the bases loaded in the first inning that saved three runs. He later smashed a three-run homer in the fifth. Sophomore Jaxon Kehoe entered in relief and mowed down all nine Cahillites to earn a perfect three-inning save.

The terrain proved much more rugged a week later against Devon Prep. Trailing 4-3 in the sixth, the Friars tied the game on a single by sophomore CJ Nocella that scored sophomore Austin Cannon, who had led off with a walk.

In the seventh, the aforementioned Carr began the winning rally with a single and advanced to third on a double by Anderson. Carr came home on an infield grounder by Sousa to make a winner out of Kehoe, who downed all five of his batters in relief to earn the victory.

“My first thought coming up to the plate was to sit fastball and get on base any way I could,” said Carr. “We were looking to score and do anything we could to get the win.

“Michael got a good piece of that ball and I really couldn’t just keep running. I had to find the ball and keep inching my way towards second base ‘til I saw the ball fall. I don’t think I could’ve scored, but that was a great hit that put me into scoring position.

“Then James Sousa had a 2-1 count and hit it to the shortstop, who bobbled it and it went into left field, which led to me walking home to score the winning run.

“It was awesome. It was my first walk-off win with the team and it felt really good. Everyone was just really excited and pumped to get the win.”

Bonner-Prendergast vs. Roman Catholic Highlights by John Knebels:

A pair of Bonner-Prendergast sophomores - pitcher Jaxon Kehoe & centerfielder Irvin Fisher both starred in the Friars' 8-0 win vs. ROman Catholic in a PCL season opener - Video by John Knebels

On the third pitch of the game, McGonigle clubbed a home run.

“It was awesome to get us on the board early on and get the boys pumped up,” said McGonigle. “It was a great team win today. If I got a big hit and we end up losing, it doesn’t matter. That big hit wouldn’t have been good enough to help the team win. But the boys fought today and we enjoyed the big win.”

McGonigle lauded Carr’s lead-off single that sparked the winning tally.

“It was huge,” he said. “Harry was confident, and I knew he was going to get on and help the team out.”

Bonner-Prendergast coach Steve DeBarberie appreciates Carr’s transition.

“It was great to see,” said DeBarberie. “He has been hitting into some tough outs. He is adjusting on the fly how teams are pitching him differently. He went from the eight-hole most of last year as a freshman to the three-hole right now as a sophomore. We have all the confidence in him, as well as the rest of our players.

*****

After stampeding to an undefeated season in the PCL last year and later capturing the PIAA state title, La Salle has experienced uncharacteristic struggles.

The Explorers are 1-2, with both losses at home. However, every PCL coach realizes that a week from now, or come playoff time, La Salle remains the team to beat. That’s just how it goes when you’re the defending champion.

“It's never a good time to lose,” said La Salle coach Kyle Werman. “But this is a different year and a different team that has to learn what it takes to win. 

“The game doesn't just hand out wins. You need to play the game the right way and it will reward you. There is some value in getting tested by good teams early in the year. It forces you to confront your areas of weakness and magnifies the importance of the details that lead to winning baseball. In that regard, an early loss can be formative.”

La Salle junior Tahir Parker, said despite a rough start, the Explorer's are still confident they can contend for another PCL title - PSD video by Mark Zimmaro

*****

At 1-3, Lansdale Catholic is undergoing growing pains, but the Crusaders know how to win.

In their opener against visiting Cardinal O’Hara, junior Mark O’Brien issued an outstanding seven inning, five-hit, one-walk performance on the mound, but the Crusaders trailed 1-0 heading into the seventh.

In LC’s home half, O’Brien delivered a two-run double that scored seniors Ryan Martinez and Jack Ferko for the walk-off success.

Although O’Hara is 0-3, the Lions have competed well against Archbishop Wood (4-0 loss) and Archbishop Carroll (3-0 loss), two teams that are currently a combined 7-0 in the PCL.

“We played some very good teams this week and three games in three days is rough – no excuse there, just reality,” said Lansdale Catholic coach Brian Ferko. “But a big part of this stretch this week was our guys learning what it means to compete in the Catholic League. How focused we need to be each inning, each pitch.

“We learned this week how important the little things are in how we perform – footwork, rounding bases correctly, getting behind the ball in the outfield, hitting our spots as a pitcher to set up the next pitch, pitch sequence, fouling off pitches to stay alive at the plate.

“We had a crash course in Catholic League baseball this week and told the boys we have four days here to rest up, think about what just happened and what we need to do better so we can get back on track," added Ferko.

Lansdale Catholic vs. Cardinal O'Hara PCL Opening Day Highlights 4/4 - PSD Highlights by James Williamson

A quad of LC senior captains reflect on their opening victory vs. O'hara - PSD Video by James Williamson

BOYS LACROSSE:

Needing only one point to reach the career century mark for points, Lansdale Catholic senior Pat McKeever couldn’t wait to play against Archbishop Carroll last Monday.

His mission didn’t take long.

On an assist to star senior Connor Mann, McKeever became the second LC player to reach 100 points since . . . Mann, who is only 14 points from reaching 200.    


Lansdale Catholic senior Pat McKeever scored his 100th goal in a 14-2 win vs. Archbishop Carroll on April 4th - Photo Courtesy of @LansdaleCatholicLarosse Instagram

“I definitely could not have done without my teammates and coaches,” said McKeever. “Getting my 100th on an assist to Connor is like lot of them. It helps so much playing with such a great scorer like Connor.”

McKeever also singled out seniors Mikey Kleinert, Colin Corbett, and Pat Cooney for “feeding me and finishing my passes.”

“I’ve got the best teammates in the world at LC,” said McKeever. “They all gave me support along with Coach Princehorn as always.”

If not for the pandemic that cost him his entire sophomore season, Mann would have ended his career as the school’s all-time leading scorer.

But the Belmont Abbey College-bound Mann was more interested in talking about his teammate.

“Pat is probably one of the most hard working kids I’ve ever met,” said Mann. “He will be there before practice shooting and after practice shooting. He worked harder than anyone this off-season, even though he was coming off a very impressive junior season.”

Lansdale Catholic coach Mark Princehorn echoed his star player’s sentiments.

“Pat McKeever is the blueprint for what you want a player to be like on the field, off the field, in the community, at school, and in the locker room,” said Princehorn. “He’s a fabulous leader and fantastic teammate. He comes to work each day with a huge chip on his shoulder and it shows.

“He’s got a relentless motor and incredible work ethic. He gets it done in every phase and checks every box for what a coach wants in a player.”

*****

After losing its league opener to St. Joseph’s Prep, Devon Prep has won four straight, and in dominant fashion.

The Tide has outscored their four foes, 63-23. When they return, they will face Father Judge and La Salle in consecutive road games.

“I think the commitment this offseason from players on the team was one of the best we have ever seen,” said Devon Prep coach Mark Consolo. “They wanted to get stronger and work on areas of their game they knew needed to improve.

“Some of the early wins thus far in the league is a tribute to that for sure. We have a majority of young players after graduating nine seniors from last year, so they are excited to be contributing through the first half of the season. In addition, our current seniors have been phenomenal leaders and mentors on both sides of the field. They are the reason our culture is strong.”

Consolo said injuries and “tough” non-league losses could be blessings in disguise.

“It’s good for us,” he said. “It’s been great to see them as a group respond with positivity and keep battling to make the program better. They take the ‘family’ chant in the huddles to heart and show it on and off the field. We are proud of them so far, but know we have a long way to go.” 

*****

Atop the standings on its usual perch stands La Salle.

The 4-0 Explorers appear as formidable as ever. Their most recent success – 12-2 at traditional championship finalist St. Joseph’s Prep – undoubtedly left the rest of the league mumbling same old, same old.

La Salle seniors Franky Fix & Henry Troy reflect on win vs. SJPrep. Video: Tommy Muir

La Salle vs. St. Joseph's Prep Highlights, Weds. April 14, SCore 12-2, by Zack Beavers

Coach Rob Forster comments on La Salle's lasting success - Video: Tommy Muir

“St. Joe’s put up a great fight,” said La Salle senior Jack Pilling, who contributed two goals and one assist. “They have some extremely talented players and it was a battle from start to finish. 

“A huge shout out should go to our defense. Keeping St. Joe’s in check is no easy task. They did a great job and helped get us possessions on the offensive end.” 

VOLLEYBALL:

Teams that face La Salle in a volleyball match have nothing to lose.

The Explorers have won the last five PCL crowns. Since defeating Roman Catholic three sets to one on April 15, 2019, not only have the Explorers not lost a PCL match – they haven’t even lost a set.

Including the three triumphs at the one-third part of this season, La Salle’s set shutout streak has reached 22.

“I don’t think there is much pressure to keep up our success, as we are constantly making each other better at practice and improving as a program,” said LaSalle senior setter Jake Barton. “Our coach, Jason Eisele, preaches that we are brothers who look out for each other and are always looking to make each other better.

“Every game, we play with the mentality of winning, but more importantly, winning with respect to our opponent. With our personnel and coaching staff, I believe the tradition of winning will continue.”

The only other undefeated squad in the PCL is St. Joseph’s Prep. The two 3-0 rivals will meet immediately after Easter break – April 18 at the Prep. They face each other again at La Salle on May 4.

See Recap from La Salle vs. Wood here:

*****

St. Joseph’s Prep opened PCL play with a 3-0 victory vs. Archbishop Wood. The Prep won the first set 25-10, the second set 25-22 and the third set 25-18. The Hawks were led with great performances from freshman libero, Fernando Nido, and junior captain, Jack Owens.

The freshman jitters did not exist for Nido, as the talented underclassman exuded confidence after the Hawks initial win. Nido dished out great passes all night, which made it possible for every Prep outside hitter, especially Owens, to get to work. He credited his great performance to his teammates.

“The hitters weren’t as quick or strong as I expected, and I was always able to find the hole in the block,” said Nido. “When everyone’s firing on all cylinders like today, that really opens things up for our outside hitters.”

Click here to see full-story by SJPrep Jr. Reporter Zach Reagan.

(Contact John Knebels at jknebels@gmail or on Twitter @johnknebels.)