skip navigation

BASEBALL: Pitching and Defense Provide Catholic League with Opening Carpenter Cup Win

By Marc Narducci. Photos: Tommy Muir, 06/15/22, 10:00PM EDT

Share

Photos/Videos: Marc Narducci & Tommy Muir

By: Marc Narducci

PHILADELPHIA – It doesn’t matter what level, the same principle remains for winning a baseball game – pitching and defense usually rule.

The Philadelphia Catholic League proved that with an opening 9-3 win over a talented Jersey Shore team during the 36th annual 16-team single-elimination Carpenter Cup at FDR Park.

The Catholic League had one hiccup, allowing three runs in the top of the second inning to fall behind 3-2.

After that it was shutout city as Bonner-Prendergast right-hander Michael Anderson threw three scoreless and hitless innings. That was followed by three more shutout innings by Archbishop Carroll left-hander Roman Tozzi and then La Salle right-hander Kevin Kell finished matters by putting up a zero in the ninth inning.

There was one other notable goose egg – in the error column for the Catholic League.

Meanwhile Jersey Shore committed four errors that led to five unearned runs.

That was too many runs to give this pitching staff, which included Father Judge sophomore David Rodriguez, who threw the first two innings and earned the win.

“We talked about it at tryouts, we knew we had good pitching in the league and we have like six college guys pitching,” said Carroll’s Tozzi, who will attend Division II Barton College in North Carolina.

Of course, Tozzi made sure to point out that his team did score nine runs, no matter how many of them were earned.

“The offense gave us a lead and it is easy to pitch with a lead,” Tozzi said.

With the sun bearing down on this mid ‘80’s day, nothing was easy, even though this staff made things look that way.

And the offense more than pitched it.


Bonner-Prendergast senior pitcher Michael Anderson - PSD Photo by Tommy Muir

Catholic League vs. Jersey Shore - Highlights by Marc Narducci

Trailing 3-2, the Catholic League took the lead for good with three runs in the bottom of the second inning. Neumann-Goretti senior second baseman Sal Laimo tied the score on an RBI double and then two more scored on an RBI infield single by Bonner-Prendergast senior catcher Joey DeMucci. The second of the runs scored on an overthrow in an attempt to get DeMucci out at first.

The Catholic League extended the lead to 8-3 with three unearned runs in the fifth off Central Regional senior Cam Leiter, the nephew of former Major Leaguer Al Leiter who also played at the same high school.

Cam Leiter was dominant, but he couldn’t overcome his defense. Still, credit La Salle senior right fielder Aidan Bretschnieder with an impressive RBI single off Leiter.

The scoring concluded with a sixth-inning RBI single by Archbishop Wood junior center fielder Joey Gale.

What is interesting, as with many All-Star teams, is that during the season the players don’t particularly have an affinity for each other.

Once teammates, that changes.

“You are competing against these guys all year and you learn to hate them on the field, but now that we are playing together it is awesome, it’s a great experience,” said La Salle’s Kell, who will take his talents to Fairfield University.

That is because talent appreciates talent, regardless of the uniform they wear.

“You get to respect how good the PCL actually is and we get to compete together and it is really cool,” Kell said.

Still, the coolest part of this tournament still awaits the eight quarterfinal teams.

The Catholic League will face Burlington County in Friday’s 12:30 p.m. quarterfinal at FDR Park.

In most seasons the semifinal and championship games are played at Citizens Bank Park, an extraordinary way of reaching out to the baseball community by the Phillies.

This year there was a conflict with Citizens Bank Park, so the final will be at FDR Park on Monday. Still the semifinals will take place at Citizens Bank Park on Sunday at 9 a.m. and 12:30 p.m.

The biggest carrot dangling for every team is the chance to play at the Phillies stadium.

High School players are still awed at the chance to take the field at Citizens Bank Park.

“It would be awesome to play at Citizens Bank Park, it would be a dream,” Kell said.

The word “awesome” comes up quite a bit when mentioning playing in the MLB park of the home team.

“It would be awesome playing in the home team’s stadium,” said Bonner-Prendie’s Anderson, a Rhode Island commit. “Just to compete there, would be a great experience.”

Of course, standing in the way is a talented Burlington County team, looking to continue carrying the recent New Jersey Carpenter Cup banner.

A New Jersey team has won the last four Carpenter Cup titles. Tri-Cape won last year. (There was no 2020 tournament due to COVID). Burlington County was the 2019 champ, Olympic-Colonial won in 2018 and Jersey Shore in 2017.

So, the Catholic League will have its work cut out, but so will Burlington County.

The key of course will be pitching.

Archbishop Carroll left-hander Roman Tozzi, who threw 3 scoreless innings, talks about what it would mean to win one more game and get to Citizens Bank Park - Video by Marc Narducci

Philadelphia Catholic League Manager Jim DiGuiseppe Sr. talks about the key to the 9-3 opening Carpenter Cup win over Jersey Shore - Video by Marc Narducci

Carpenter Cup rules state a pitcher can’t throw more than three innings in a game.

Andrerson, Tozzi and Kell all said they would be willing to pitch Friday but stated respectfully that it would be up to manager Jim DiGuiseppe Sr. and his Catholic League staff.

DiGuiseppe is the former head coach of Archbishop Wood for 17 seasons. The last 10 years he has assisted his son Jim Jr. at Wood.

His son is on this Carpenter Cup staff and the elder DiGuiseppe quipped “now he has to listen to me.”

The elder DiGuiseppe says it’s likely that he could get innings on Friday from the pitchers who threw in the opener. He also mentioned that Father Judge senior John Westfield, who played first base in the win, is also among the pitchers who can be used. (Teams must designate before the game if a player will pitch or be a position player).


2022 Philadelphia Catholic League Carpenter Cup Team - PSD Photo by Marc Narducci

Whether he can book a trip to Citizens Bank Park or not, the elder DiGuiseppe is having a blast. This is the 13th season he has been affiliated with the Catholic League Carpenter Cup team.

“It’s really a pleasure to coach these guys,” he said.

More so when he can send players to the mound who put up consistent zeroes on the scoreboard.