skip navigation

GIRLS BASKETBALL: Classic PCL Regular Season Gives Way to Playoff Quarterfinals

By John Knebels, 02/15/23, 3:15PM EST

Share

Photos/Videos: Donna Eckert, John Knebels, Mike Nance, Jack Verdeur, Krystal Williams

By: John Knebels

PHILADELPHIA – Dig deep into the annals of the Philadelphia Catholic League and try to find something that imitated the regular season that ended this past Saturday.

Won’t find it.

For the first time in league history, three teams finished tied for first place with records of 9-1 and required three tiebreakers to decipher final standings. After considering head-to-head and then common opponents, the next decider was best point differential among the trio.

Thus, Lansdale Catholic snared first place, Archbishop Wood nabbed second, and Cardinal O’Hara seized third. Each of those squads, along with fourth-place Archbishop Carroll, will host first-round games on February 16. After re-seeding if necessary, the final four will compete in the PCL semifinals at St. Joseph University’s University City campus (730 South 43rd Street) on February 21, and then the two survivors will meet in the league championship 6 PM February 27 at the famed Palestra.

“That COVID-shortened year (2020-21), we were in the Red Division and we took our lickings,” said Lansdale Catholic coach Eric Gidney, referring to an 0-11 finish against the PCL larger-enrollment schools after having gone undefeated in the smaller-school Catholic Blue the previous season. “So from a body of work standpoint, from where we were then to where we are now, being the number-one seed, yeah, it’s great.

“At the end of the day, it doesn’t mean anything. What we do with that seeding is the most important part.”

Lansdale Catholic senior standout Gabby Casey agrees.

Lansdale Catholic vs. Archbishop Carroll - PSD Game Highlights by John Knebels

A few minutes after scoring a game-high 21 points to help defeat host Archbishop Carroll, 42-39, in a stirring regular-season finale on February 9, the St. Joseph’s University-bound guard was aware that the Crusaders had just clinched first place overall for the first time since joining the league for the 2008-09 season.

“It’s amazing,” said Casey. “It’s just great to see the hard work we put into throughout the offseason and even during the season prevail. We keep pushing forward. This is only a small step to what we want to accomplish here.”

After scoring 21 points in win vs. Carroll, Gabby Casey talks about LC taking the PCL's top seed - PSD Video by John Knebels

LC coach Eric Gidney is pleased - but not satisfied - with PCL regular-season title - PSD Video by John Knebels

A loss to Carroll would have created a seismic shift in the upcoming playoff schedule. If Carroll had successfully erased a 23-13 halftime deficit, the Patriots would have finished third and Lansdale Catholic would have dropped all the way to fourth. Meanwhile, Archbishop Wood and Cardinal O’Hara would have finished one-two.

In the end, however, the regular season’s most important game turned out to be Lansdale Catholic’s stunning 49-31 win at Wood on February 7. With seniors Jaida Helm (17 points) and Casey (13 points, nine points, three blocks, three steals) a major force start to finish, the Vikings scored their fewest points in a PCL game since losing to Archbishop Carroll, 43-33, on January 4, 2019.

Junior Olivia Boccella (six points on two high-arcing three-pointers from the right corner), sophomore Nadia Yemola (six points on three athletics buckets), and sophomore Sanyiah Littlejohn (four points, pesky defense) joined the duo with memorable outings.

“It’s great,” said Helm, referring to Lansdale Catholic’s balanced scoring. “It’s really fun to play with them. It’s anybody’s night. Tonight just happened to be my night. (The next game) might be somebody else’s night.”

Five nights earlier, Lansdale Catholic had dropped a riveting 53-51 decision to visiting Cardinal O’Hara despite trailing by double digits heading into the final quarter. Littlejohn led the comeback attempt with an electric 20 points.

Helm picked up three fouls by the 6:17 mark of the first quarter. She was whistled for a fourth 1:12 into the third, eventually fouled out with seven seconds remaining in regulation, and finished scoreless. Though she scored 16 points, Casey made several uncharacteristic turnovers.

But that version of the Crusaders was nowhere to be found against Wood. Instead, Lansdale Catholic notched its most important PCL victory since entering the league 15 years ago.

“It’s just a mindset,” said Casey. “Just turn the page. Everybody has bad games here and there. You just have to go to the next one no matter what happens.

“Our intensity on defense helps our offense. Jaida had a great night scoring from everywhere (against Wood) and then everybody contributed. That started with the defense coming out with intensity.”

Archbishop Wood coach Mike McDonald accepted a large share of the blame for his team’s uncharacteristic performance.

“It comes down on me first and foremost for not settling them down, maybe run some different looks,” said McDonald, whose Vikings came one win shy of securing the program’s first undefeated regular season since the 2016-17 campaign. “We have a lot of video and things to learn about ourselves.

“They (Lansdale Catholic) played really well. We were a stop slow defensively and a step slow rebounding the basketball. Offensively, we weren’t getting anything. We weren’t moving the ball enough to get something good. We were going to the basket and kind of forcing things up. This is a much better time to lose than later on in February.”

Archbishop Wood vs. Lansdale Catholic Highlights by Donna Eckert & John KNebels

Jaida Helm & Gabby Casey combined for 30 points in LC's 49-31 win at Archbishop Wood - PSD Video by John Knebels

LC coach Eric Gidney lauds his team's dominant performance vs. a talented wood team - PSD Video by John Knebels

Archbishop Wood head coach Mike McDonald summarizes rare lopsided defeat - PSD Video by John Knebels

Wood senior Delaney Finnegan wasn’t particularly shocked that three teams finished atop the standings with only one defeat each.

“The three-way tie is really crazy, but I think that it shows how strong the PCL is,” said Finnegan. “We know we have to beat good teams this year, and what makes the PCL so competitive is that there are several very skilled teams and the games can go either way.” 

Since losing at Wood, 47-37, on January 24, Cardinal O’Hara has rattled off five straight victories, highlighted by the aforementioned win at Lansdale Catholic.

The defending champion Lions also lost only once last year, but they rebounded with a dominant performance against Archbishop Carroll in the championship.

Some figured this would be a rebuilding year for coach Chrissie Doogan. The Lions ignored the prognostication.

“This league is tough,” said sophomore Molly Rullo, who scored 20 points against Lansdale Catholic and 13 versus Wood, both team highs. “On any given night it is anyone’s game to win, so I’m not surprised by the (regular season) outcome. It makes it more fun to see the end result after playoffs.” 

Though In fourth place with a 7-3 record, Archbishop Carroll came close to forging a 9-1 mark. The Patriots blew a huge 15-0 first-quarter lead in a 40-36 loss at O’Hara, and against Lansdale Catholic, the Patriots erased a miserable 14-3 second quarter by outscoring the Crusaders by 26-19 and had a chance to tie the game or take the lead in the final minute of regulation.

In typical fashion, sisters Taylor and Brooke Wilson shouldered the bulk of the scoring. Brooke, a junior, tallied 13 of her 19 points in a brilliant second half. Taylor, a senior playing her final regulation game, scored 11 of her 16 during the same time frame.

Archbishop Carroll's Taylor Wilson scored 16 points vs. Lansdale Catholic in her last regular-season game. Now - it's onto the playoffs - PSD Video by John Knebels

“We struggled to make shots in the first half, which caused us to get down,” said Taylor. “But we came back and started to play our game in the second half. We just dug ourselves too deep in the first half.

“We learn from every game that we play, win or lose. We’re just building on everything. We will see everyone again in the playoffs.”

Each of the PCL’s top four will be favored when they host tomorrow night’s quarterfinals. Though facing uphill battles, their underdog opponents aren’t throwing in the proverbial towel, either.

Eight-seed Archbishop Ryan (3-7 league record) faces top-seed Lansdale Catholic, which defeated the visiting Ragdolls, 75-29, on January 19. After starting 0-6, Ryan won three of its final four, including a 58-40 playoff clincher at Little Flower in which Delaney Finn poured in a career-high 30 points on sizzling 10-for-18 shooting from three-point land. The junior finished the season with 65 three pointers, believed to be a school record. Sophomore Reynah Rattliff surpassed 100 assists for the season.

“We are happy, but not satisfied,” said Ryan coach Julian Rattliff. “We understand that we have to turn it up a notch and believe we have another level to hit before the season ends. I'm looking forward to my ladies gaining the experience to hopefully push us forward in the future.

“This is great for the Archbishop Ryan girls’ basketball program. This is only the beginning of what we want to do with this program. I'm truly grateful for this group, including my coaching staff.”

Seven-seed Conwell-Egan (4-6) meets two-seed Archbishop Wood. In a PCL opener on January 5, the visiting Eagles lost, 65-28. 

Conwell-Egan coach Chris Brennan will need big games from – in particular – senior post Kyliyah Carmichael and sophomore point guard Lily Milewski. He acknowledged that the Eagles face an uphill battle going against a team that overwhelmed them six weeks earlier, but said his team has improved since then despite having lost junior captain Mya Aizen to a season-ending injury in mid-January.

“We are also playing with more confidence,” said Brennan. “Since opening the PCL season with Wood, we have had a lot of opportunities to address issues since then.”  

Six-seed West Catholic (5-5) lost to Cardinal O’Hara, 55-21, in a regular-season finale on Feb. 9. Now, the Burrs take on the three-seed Lions in a rematch.

The Burrs have received spirited contributions from senior Amina Reid, freshman Jalyn Moore, freshman Jasmine Butler, and junior Laila Farmer, the latter coming off a 17-point output in a huge win over Conwell-Egan and then 22 against Little Flower. Moore contributed consecutive double doubles.   

“O’Hara is a very good team as knew going into our last game against them,” said West Catholic coach Messiah Reames. “But having the opportunity to play them a week later while things are still fresh will give us the chance to learn from our mistakes and not make them in our playoff game. We will need to stick to our game plan in order to have success.”

O’Hara’s aforementioned junior Joanie Quinn doesn’t think either team will have a true advantage having played about a week apart. 

“I think it is probably neutral,” said Quinn. “They are fresh in our memory and vice-versa. I think we just need to focus on playing our game – playing great defense and getting good shots in the flow of our offense.”

The most anticipated quarterfinal features five-seed Neumann-Goretti (6-4) battling four-seed Archbishop Carroll. The Saints struggled against the visiting Patriots on February 2, losing 67-49.

As a five-seed last year, the Saints surprised Lansdale Catholic, 66-52, after having lost to the Crusaders, 71-64, just 12 nights earlier.

Neumann-Goretti coach Andrea Peterson, a former Archbishop Carroll star who scored the winning free throw in a 36-35 championship win over Cardinal O’Hara in 2003, and then amassed 10 points, six assists, and three steals in a 56-33 title victory win over O’Hara in 2004, now faces her alma mater in the playoffs for a second straight season (50-35 loss in last year’s semifinals) and third since 2018 (48-47 win in semifinals).

After receiving particularly consistent production from sophomores Carryn Easley and Amya Scott, Peterson was asked to compare a playoff game to a regular-season tilt.

“I wouldn’t say there is a completely different mindset because I approach every game the same way,” said Peterson, “but it does give you time to reset and regroup and reflect on positives and negatives.

“We focus on what we can do better the second time around. The mentality of survive and advance . . . leave it all on the floor and leave with no regrets.”

 

(Contact John Knebels via email at jknebels@gmail.com or on Twitter @johnknebels.)