skip navigation

PCL SOFTBALL: Several Huge Upcoming Games Will Decide Playoff Seeding

By John Knebels, 04/29/24, 2:30PM EDT

Share

By John Knebels

(Photos by Carlos Otero)

PHILADELPHIA – Fall sports begin in late August and finish in December. Winter sports start in November and keep going through the end of March.

The spring? Blink once, sneeze twice . . . and it’s over.

Even though it seems like Philadelphia Catholic League softball just began, it’s already more than half over. So better not waste any time perusing a mid-to-late season update.

Though they won’t make the playoffs – only six (instead of eight) of the 11 teams qualify, something the PCL brain trust hopefully rectifies between this season and next – Little Flower turned in a fine overall performance on April 23 and defeated St. Hubert’s, 7-5, celebrating their first win of the season.

A five-run fourth inning and the combined pitching of seniors Ava Lawrence and Meaghan Dugan complemented the hitting of freshman Violet Becker (two runs scored, a two-run triple), freshman Kelly Trahey (two RBI), and Dugan (two hits, two RBI).

Down 7-2, Hubert’s (1-6) scored three runs in a nail-biting seventh inning and had the bases loaded with one out. On a chaotic final play, a high pop-up elicited an infield fly rule for the second out. A subsequent mistake on the base paths resulted in a heads-up third out when freshman shortstop Keira Hughes fired to senior Allie Szychulski, who had hustled in from center field to cover second base and apply the game-ending tag. Earlier in the sixth, Szychulski, a third-team All-Catholic last year, made a terrific sliding catch.

Little Flower vs. St. Hubert Game Highlights by John Knebels for PSD.

Head Coach Tori Sherwood received contributions from numerous players in 7-5 win over St. Hubert’s. (video/ John Knebels for PSD)

“It feels great,” said Little Flower coach Tori Sherwood. “It was a big team win. One through nine really contributed. We’ve been struggling during the games, but the girls work really hard every day at practice. The hitting was contagious. For them to pull together to get that win over St. Hubert’s is big for all of us, coaches and players.”

Senior Allie Szychulski’s key defensive plays helped Little Flower notch a PCL win. (video/ John Knebels)

Seniors Meaghan Davis and Ava Lawrence pitched Little Flower past St. Hubert’s. (video/ John Knebels)

As for the teams atop the division, Archbishop Ryan remains the only undefeated team. At 6-0, the Ragdolls’ final four opponents – Cardinal O’Hara, Archbishop Carroll, Conwell-Egan, and Bonner-Prendergast – have amassed a 20-5 collective record.

In their most recent win on a ridiculously cold evening on April 25, the Ragdolls scored in every inning and used a six-run sixth to cement a closer-than-it-appears 16-6 win over Archbishop Wood, which came into the game with a 5-1 record.

Ryan’s first three hitters proved almost unstoppable, combining for seven hits, eight runs scored, and 10 RBI. Senior Kayla Gray (4-for-4, walk, double, four runs scored, two RBI), junior Moira Maw (2-4, home run, whopping six RBI), and senior Mya Diorio (home run, two RBI, four straight intentional walks) spearheaded a 16-hit attack that included senior Rudy Taruwinga’s three hits, two RBI, and home run.

Ryan vs. Wood. Highlights by John Knebels for PSD

Maddie Velez tossed four strong innings to earn the pitching victory. From innings three through six, the junior allowed two runs and four hits while striking out nine. She also added an RBI single.

Archbishop Ryan’s Maddie Velez earned the pitching win over Archbishop Wood

(L-R) Moira Maw, Kayla Gray, and Mya Diorio combined for 10 RBI in win over Archbishop Wood.

“I don’t really care as long I’m helping my team out,” said Velez, referring to either entering in relief of Maw or starting the game on her own. “Me and Maura have a great relationship. Either way, we’re coming in the game knowing, ‘I’m helping you out, or you’re helping me out.’”  

At 6-1, Archbishop Carroll began with five wins and a scoring advantage of 56 to 7.  The Patriots then dropped a 7-6 decision at Conwell-Egan after relinquishing a 6-3 lead in the seventh inning, and bounced back to defeat Nazareth Academy, 9-5. The Patriots’ next two challenges – visits to Archbishop Wood and Archbishop Ryan – will decide their playoff seeding.

“The loss against Egan was a disappointment,” said Carroll junior Dakotah Johnson. “Today’s win (against Nazareth, in which she belted two homers and knocked in four runs) was a huge step to get back to the win column. Everyone, one through nine, contributed in today’s win.”

In Carroll’s most important win – 5-1 at Cardinal O’Hara on April 15 – Johnson’s complete-game pitching gem (five hits allowed, seven strikeouts) was aided by freshman Emily Russ’ two-run triple in the first inning and two hits apiece by Johnson and junior Maddie Long.

Cardinal O’Hara rebounded from the defeat to win their next four, and with three future opponents – Archbishop Ryan, Conwell-Egan, and Archbishop Wood – sporting a collective record of 16-3, the Lions have plenty of work to do.

Archbishop Carroll vs. Cardinal O'Hara Game Highlights by John Knebels for PSD

Archbishop Carroll coach Mike Lorine lauds his players after win over O'Hara. (video/ John Knebels)

With standout junior pitcher Hayden Sissons standing on the mound, O’Hara has recorded three shutouts and allowed only one run in two other games. Earlier this season, Sissons reached the career 400-strikeout plateau.

Freshman Emily Russ belted a two-run triple in the first inning and helped Archbishop Carroll defeat Cardinal O’Hara, 5-1. (video/ John Knebela)

Archbishop Carroll Junior Pitcher Dakotah Johnson pitched a complete game and also hit a home run in 5-1 victory over O'Hara. (Video/ JOhn Knebels)

Despite losing to Carroll, Cardinal O’Hara’s Hayden Sissons pitched three strong innings and locked in a run. (video/ John Knebels)

Cardinal O’Hara coach Danny Yohey saw some positives in loss to Archbishop Carroll. (video/ John Knebels)

“Hitting 400 strikeouts is unbelievable to me,” said Sissons. “It’s a great accomplishment that I could never imagine hitting coming into O’Hara my freshman year. I am just so proud that all my hard work over these past years have paid off.”

Defending PCL champion Conwell-Egan engineered a huge 7-6 victory over visiting Archbishop Carroll on April 23. After a 3-0 lead after five innings turned into a 6-3 deficit in the seventh, the Eagles tallied four runs, with key contributions coming from senior Molly Milewski, sophomore Angelina Pandolfi, junior Cecelia McBeth, and a walk-off single by sophomore Grace Mee.

With battles against Bonner-Prendergast, Cardinal O’Hara, and Archbishop Ryan (composite record of 15-3) looming, the Eagles have placed themselves in position to make yet another title run.

“The feeling of adrenaline, eagerness, and drive is the same for each Catholic League game,” said Milewski. “Going into every game, we have one common goal – to win. It is a matter of how – through defense, or offense, or both.”

Archbishop Wood (5-2) more than survived an early-season test. After giving up a stunning 10 runs in the sixth inning and falling at Bonner-Prendergast, 13-6, on April 15, the Vikings turned frowns into smiles 24 hours later by defeating visiting Conwell-Egan, 5-1, behind brilliant pitching by sophomore Jackie Cobb (five hits allowed over seven innings) and five runs in the home fifth.

Two days later at Nazareth Academy, the Vikings fell behind, 2-0, but the offense of senior Parker Kraus (3-4, three runs scored), sophomore Allison Siegfried (2-3, walk, triple, two runs scored, two RBI), and junior Sophia Azzarano (2-4, two RBI) and another strong outing by Cobb (seven-hitter, six strikeouts) etched a 7-3 win.

Sophomore Jackie Cobb fired a 5-1, complete-game win over Conwell Egan on 4/16. (video/ JOhn Knebels)

Captains Julia Yogis, Parker Kraus, and Maura Yoos celebrate early-season win over Conwell-Egan

Senior Elise Cawley made several nice plays at shortstop in 5-1 win over Conwell-Egan. (video/ John Knebels)

On April 25, the Vikings lost at Archbishop Ryan by a misleading final score of 16-6. A two-run single by Kraus and two-run homer by Cobb brought Wood to within a manageable 9-6 heading into the home fifth.

“I would say we’re in a pretty good spot,” said Wood senior tri-captain Julia Yogis. “We’ve worked extremely hard this season to get to the point where we are and make sure we work as a team. The past few games have definitely showed our ability to play as a team and play to win.

“Although Ryan was a tough loss, I’m proud of how we battled. Some of us know what it’s like to play Ryan while others have never experienced that before. It was a good first face off, but now we know what we need to work on. I think if we continue to work hard and play cohesively the next few weeks, we will definitely put ourselves in a good spot right before playoffs.”

Wood coach Jackie Ecker has received contributions from many different players in game vs. Nazareth. (video/ John Knebels)

Arch. Wood catcher Sophia Arrazano supplies offense and defense in win over Nazareth Academy. (video/ John Knebels)

Archbishop Wood sophomore Allison Siegfried had a big day at the plate in win over Nazareth Academy. (video/ John Knebels)

Coming up on May 2 is a pivotal meeting between two programs that share the same Pandas mascot – Nazareth Academy at Bonner-Prendergast. A win by B-P would virtually assure a playoff spot; because of tiebreakers, a victory by Nazareth could ultimately be enough to secure a postseason visit in the school’s PCL debut.

For Bonner-Prendergast, three straight wins have put the Pandas at 3-2. On April 15, coming off two lopsided defeats, the Pandas received important relief pitching from freshman Cara Schaffer and key hitting from freshmen Mara George and Camryn Mariani in a 13-6, come-from-behind triumph over Archbishop Wood. Wins at St. Hubert’s and Neumann-Goretti followed.

Along with being considered an upset, the victory over Wood gave first-year Prendergast coach Meghan Sullivan – a former pitching star at her B-P alma mater – her first-ever PCL victory.   

“Getting that first win was a huge confidence boost,” said Sullivan. “A much-needed win to account for all of the hard work the girls have been putting in. A team win is huge to see everyone from top to bottom and all over the field partake.

“Winning as a coach is a whole different kind of winning. It’s watching the little things fall into place, getting the bunt down, throwing the girl out at second, or the girl struggling to get that hit that makes it all worth it.

“Pandas softball continues to get one percent better every single day. We are starting to jell at the right time and we are working out the kinks. We have a strong, talented group of young girls who are eager to learn and get better. The best part of this team is they are a family, they take care of each other, and they continue to pick each other up. They celebrate everyone’s victories as their own and continue to push each other to be the best versions of themselves. I’m very proud of this young team and excited for their success to follow.” 

For Nazareth Academy, a 2-5 record belies visible daily improvement. Following nine-run losses against Archbishop Ryan and Conwell-Egan, the Pandas defeated Lansdale Catholic, lost to Archbishop Wood, defeated Neumann-Goretti, and then dropped an impressively close 6-4 decision at Cardinal O’Hara.

On April 25 against visiting Archbishop Carroll, Nazareth sophomore Breanne Logan knocked in three runs and helped keep her team stay to within 7-5 after five innings. Although the Pandas eventually lost, 9-5, the Pandas proved they could hang with the league’s top squads. 

“Defensively, plays that we were not making a few weeks ago or even a few games ago, we made today,” said Nazareth coach Danielle Vititto. “We have had a lot of conversations with the outfield and they put in hard work this past week. Today we saw balls being cut off, hits or extra bases being taken away that we haven’t before. The outfield played a good game today.

“Offensively, we had runners on base every inning but the seventh, and were putting the ball in play consistently. We have some players who are really stepping up and doing good things offensively. Our work ethic as a whole has stepped up, and positive changes are being made every day.”

In a 12-6 loss to Nazareth Academy, Lansdale Catholic junior Lauren Leshak notched her 300th career strikeout.

“It’s great to reach milestones because it shows me that my hard work in the offseason is paying off, and I’ll continue to improve,” said Leshak. “My teammates have been very supportive the past three years and have made it a lot of fun.”

Neumann-Goretti has two more chances to snare a victory – April 30 against Little Flower and May 2 versus St. Hubert’s.

Nazareth Academy coach Danielle Vititto sees positive signs despite loss to Archbishop Wood. (Video/ John Knebels)


Lansdale Catholic junior pitcher Lauren Leshak marks career 300th strikeout in game vs. Nazareth Academy (PSD file photo by Geanine Jamison)

“Right now the focus is on building a team,” said Saints first-year coach Tina Kelly. “Players are learning. We are building and learning and having fun with it – losses and all. We are bringing back the love of the game.”

(John Knebels can be reached at jknebels@gmail.com or on ‘X’ @johnknebels.)