skip navigation

GIRLS BASKETBALL: With PCL's Regular Season Entering Fourth Quarter, Clarity Emerges

By John Knebels, 02/03/26, 4:15PM EST

Share

BY JOHN KNEBELS

(VIDEO/ JOHN KNEBELS: PHOTOS BY MIKE SZCZEPKOWSKI, RILEY SCHWARZ & MARK ZIMMARO)

PHILADELPHIA – With about one-third of the regular season remaining, each of the Philadelphia Catholic League’s 12 coaches was asked to assess a highlight or two so far. As we go to press, a few have not responded.

Archbishop Carroll appears to be a lock to finish undefeated in the regular season for the first time in four years. At 8-0, the Patriots have amassed key victories over defending champion Neumann-Goretti (47-40), Cardinal O’Hara (51-28), and Archbishop Wood (44-38). Carroll has outscored its foes by an average of 22 points per game.

The starting unit of seniors Alexis Eberz and Bridget Grant, juniors Cate Schumacher and Abbie McFillin, and sophomore Kayla Eberz—arguably the league’s MVP so far—has given opponents all kinds of fits ever since the season began with a brutal onslaught of rugged competition.

“I think just coming to practice every day with a positive mindset and giving 100% every time we step on the court and scouting and knowing the personnel for the team that we are playing against,” said Alexis Eberz. “We have a really good mix of seniors and underclassmen on our team. Seeing everyone develop in practice and games is really cool. Watching the younger people grow as an upperclassman is a blessing.”

Carroll’s top five starters continue to set the tone on both ends of the floor.

“Watching the team grow offensively and defensively has been the best part,” said Carroll coach Renie Shields. “We’ve had a number of assists increasing as the season moves on.”

Sisters Kayla and Alexis Eberz combined for 37 pts and 21 REB in Carroll's win over Neumann-Goretti.

Archbishop Carroll vs. Neumann Goretti in game on January 20th. (video/ John Knebels)

Bridget Grant aided Carroll’s win over rival Cardinal O’Hara.

Kayla Eberz assesses Carroll's win over rival Cardinal O'Hara.

At 7-1, defending champion Neumann-Goretti’s only blemish was a 47-40 loss at Archbishop Carroll in a battle between last year’s two finalists. The Saints got past Archbishop Wood, 36-33, Monday night. A Tuesday meeting with visiting Cardinal O’Hara will determine the two and three seed when the playoffs arrive.

Senior Kamora Berry (11 points per game) and junior Reginna Baker (17) both reached 1,000 career points this season. Freshman point guard Azzure O’Connor has averaged five assists and nine points.

“We’re finally hitting our stride after playing a tough non-league schedule,” said Saints coach Andrea Peterson. “Going through last year and winning both the PCL and states helps a lot because of the experience. Once you get the feel of winning the PCL and states, it motivates you to do it again – especially the feeling from the PCL environment at the Palestra. There’s nothing like it.”

The highlight of Cardinal O’Hara’s 7-1 start was a 46-37 win over Archbishop Wood. The Lions could finish as high as second place if they can defeat Neumann-Goretti on Feb. 3.

Senior Meg Rullo averages 14 points, five rebounds, and four assists, while junior Leah Hudak is next on the team in scoring at nine points per game.

“We had a great team win over a Rutgers Prep earlier this month, but I would say the highlight for me so far this year is seeing Meg Rullo and (junior) Bre Davis back on the court after both missed last year due to ACL injuries,” said O’Hara coach Chrissie Doogan. “It takes a lot to recover from the injury both physically and mentally, and I am so proud of both of them for rehabbing and playing so well this year. Meg is leading our team in points, rebounds, and assists so far this year. Bre is probably the best sixth man in the league.”

NEUMANN-GORETTI COACH ANDREA PETERSON LAUDS HER TEAM'S DEFENSE AFTER BIG WIN VS. WOOD.

Neumann-Goretti in Last night's PCL Game vs. Archbishop Wood (video/John Knebels)

A young, defense-oriented Archbishop Wood squad nearly pulled off an upset Friday night before falling to undefeated Archbishop Carroll, 44-38. At 5-3, the Vikings are likely staring at a fourth-place finish come playoff time.

All of Wood’s losses have come at the hands of talent-laden opponents, including national power Mount Zion, a two-point loss to defending Inter-Ac champion Notre Dame Academy while missing three players, Cardinal O’Hara after leading into the fourth quarter, and the aforementioned back-and-forth games versus Carroll and Neumann-Goretti.

Defensively, the Vikings held Archbishop Ryan to 25 points (eight in the second half), Lansdale Catholic to 22 points (11 in each half), and Carroll to a PCL season-low 44.

coach Mike McDonald was proud of his team despite loss to undefeated Carroll

Archbishop Wood vs. Archbishop Carroll on Jan. 29th. (video/ John Knebels)

Wood's Abbie Kelly recognizes her team’s continued improvement.

Wood has maintained balanced scoring behind sophomore Zoey Whalen (10.4 points), sophomore Abbie Kelly (10), and junior Makayla Finnegan (9.2). Junior Sophia McDonald leads the team in assists, fewest turnovers, and steals. Senior standout Colleen Besachio has returned from last year’s injuries and has visibly displayed more confidence. Sophomores Casey Thompson and Addison Payne have led the team in rebounding, while senior Emma Yogis continues to stretch the floor as Wood’s top three-point shooter.

“If we can find the confidence to take and make the right shots,” said coach Mike McDonald, “we feel we can win on any given night in the league as our defense keeps us in it.”

Wood's Zoey Whalen set a career high with 17 points in win over Nazareth Academy.

Archbishop Wood in game vs. Nazareth Academy on January 22nd.

Colleen Besachio back from Last year's injury to aid in Wood's win vs. Nazareth

All of Archbishop Ryan’s four PCL wins have been by double digits. All of their losses have come against the league’s perennial top four programs. Their most impressive showing came in Saturday’s 45-41 setback versus Cardinal O’Hara.

“We are certainly trending in the right direction,” said Ragdolls first-year coach Jimmy Dillon. “Commitment, dedication, and accountability have been three pillars that have helped the chemistry of a team featuring 11 new players along with six returning rotational players. Our three goals this season were to create a buzz about the team, change the culture of the program, and to win. We are certainly happy with the season so far, but we all realize there is a lot more work still to be done.”

Lansdale Catholic is 4-4, but the Crusaders came close to upsetting Neumann-Goretti (33-30 loss) and Cardinal O’Hara (45-41).

“Playing in the PCL, it’s very tough and having players who’ve never really played against that competition is hard,” said LC junior Allie Esposito. “But my team has really put all of that aside and came together to play at that level of competitiveness that our opponents are. Everyone is shaking off the nerves and really coming together, even though we are a young team.

“It didn’t take very long to realize that we can actually hang with the top teams in the PCL. Only losing by a few points means that if we did a couple things better, the game could’ve been ours, so that gives us a lot of hope and confidence when we see those teams again.”

With an exciting 61-48 win at West Catholic on Saturday – its fourth straight victory after starting the season with four defeats – Bonner-Prendergast is on the doorstep of clinching its first playoff berth since 2018-19.

“The highlight of our season has been watching our team grow together – building trust and strong relationships on the court,” said first-year Bonner-Prendergast coach Sarah Monaghan. “With three of our five starters new to the school, we have been fortunate to welcome such outstanding student-athletes into our program.

“Competing against a tougher non-league schedule, (sophomores) Kayla Epps and Skylar Rothley have been the driving forces behind our success, with Kayla averaging 17 points per game and Skylar providing consistency and stability throughout the season. (Sophomore) Alaya Dorsey is the type of player every coach hopes to have – someone who consistently excels at doing the little things right. (Juniors) Allie Polinski and Gionna Pagan have brought valuable experience and strong game management to the team.”

Against West Catholic, Rothley (18 points, 12 rebounds), Epps (19 points, five rebounds, five steals), Polinski (14 points, eight rebounds), sophomore London Tyler (nine rebounds), and Dorsey (eight points, with key free throws toward the end to seal the outcome) led the way.

“This was truly a team win for us,” said Monaghan, a 2014 Prendergast grad and former 11-year assistant coach to Tom Stewart. “Every player who stepped on the court contributed in a meaningful way. Kayla and Skylar have been steady leaders for us all season, but we are at our best when everyone is involved offensively. As a group with playoff aspirations, we understood the challenge of facing a tough, well-coached West Catholic team on their home court. I am extremely proud of this group and grateful for the opportunity to coach these girls in a program that means so much to me.”

St. Hubert’s is 3-4, with a key 62-48 win over West Catholic. The Bambies need two wins over their final five games to clinch a playoff berth.

“The highlight of the season so far has been the chemistry and play of my young team,” said Hubert’s coach Dave Schafer. “They are giving me everything they have no matter what the situation or score.”

Although Conwell-Egan (1-7) has only defeated Little Flower, the Eagles have displayed mettle in losses at Nazareth Academy (49-37), Archbishop Ryan (60-39), and Lansdale Catholic (43-27). Junior Jayla Butler has averaged 9.4 points per game, thanks in part to a flurry of three-pointers.

“The highlight of this season has been the overall improvement of the team as a whole,” said Conwell-Egan first-year coach Korell Velez. “We have battled injuries, sickness, and learning a new system/coaching staff.”

Rounding out the standings are West Catholic (2-6, with wins over Nazareth Academy and Little Flower), Nazareth Academy (2-6, with wins over Little Flower and Conwell-Egan), and Little Flower (0-8).

(Contact John Knebels at jknebels@gmail.com or on ‘X’ @johnknebels.)

St Hubert in game vs. Cardinal O'Hara on 1/20. (video/ Mike Livingston for PSD)