skip navigation

GIRLS' BASKETBALL: Primed For Success, Players & Coaches of the Catholic League Look to Use League Play to Prepare for the Ultimate End Goal of Winning a State Title

By Rich Flanagan - Photos: Kathy Leister , 12/14/18, 3:00PM EST

Share

By: Rich Flanagan (@richflanagan33)

PHILADELPHIA -Beulah Osueke wasn’t completely sure what to expect.

Coming in as the new head coach of West Catholic in 2013, she knew about the depth of the Philadelphia Catholic League and the talent it boasted but it was not until she was actually on the sideline witnessing it firsthand that she realized what it would take to find success. 

She saw the grind of the league and how it shapes a team over the course of the season by constantly challenging players and coaches on a nightly basis. It also prepares them for what comes after the PCL season is over and Osueke immediately noticed that.

“The Catholic League prepares you for the state run,” Osueke said. “When I first started coaching, I didn’t really understand the caliber or level of play but the Catholic League is insanely competitive from top to bottom. There’s always a chance for a new team to emerge or a team that has always been at the top to drop toward the middle.”

Despite finishing eighth in the regular season and suffering a loss to Neumann-Goretti in the PCL quarterfinals, Osueke and the Burrs rebounded to claim their fourth consecutive District 12 title and from there it was onto the PIAA Class 2A Tournament. West Catholic (16-13, 5-7 Philadelphia Catholic League) advanced to the 2A title game before falling to Bellwood-Antis, 45-42.

West Catholic vs. Steelton Highspire 2018 PIAA first round highlights:

2018 PIAA 2A West Catholic vs. Bellwood-Antis State Championship Highlights:

It was the culmination of a program returning to prominence, especially one that had finished 0-18 in 2012, the year before Osueke came on. The entire Burrs core returns including 5-6 junior point guard Tamiah Robinson (13.9 ppg), who was named a First Team All-Catholic and Pa. All-State Class 2A Second Team selection. Destiny McPhaul, a 5-7 sophomore guard who was a Second Team All-Catholic, scored 12 points in the state title game. 5-10 senior forward Kyliah Singletary, who 10 points against Bellwood-Antis, is the “heart and soul of the team,” according to Osueke, 5-9 senior forward Amiyah Edney had 15 points vs. Mahanoy Area in the state quarterfinals, and 5-10 senior forward Daja Hosendorf is the “defensive specialist,” as Osueke says.

Osueke challenged her inexperienced team last season but she knew the kind of potential they had, especially with playing in the PCL. 

“Last year, we had a very young team but I intentionally gave us a very tough schedule,” Osueke said. “We have a difficult schedule again this year. Having really tough nonleague opponents on top of playing in the Catholic League in and of itself really does prepare teams for a long run in the postseason.”

Another team that fell in a state championship game was Archbishop Wood (22-8, 11-1). After winning back-to-back state titles 2016 and 2017, the Lady Vikings lost to Mars in the PIAA 5A title game, 36-33. After suffering a four-point loss at the hands of eventual champion Cardinal O’Hara in the PCL semifinals, Archbishop Wood won its fifth straight District 12 title then made a run to the state final, its third runner-up finish since 2014. 

The loss ended a dominant run for the 2018 senior class of First Team All-Catholic and Class 5A Player of the Year Katie May (Northeastern), Second Team All-Catholic Bridget Arcidiacono (Jefferson University) and fellow Second Team All-Catholic Erin Morgan (La Salle).

Head coach Mike McDonald, who helped develop May into an impressive all-around player (avg. 8.8 points, 4.6 rebounds and 4.5 assists last season) and coached Arcidiacono since sixth grade, stressed that the state title is still imprinted in his mind.

“The lasting impression was that I can’t get the moment when we lost the state championship out of my head,” McDonald said. “I’ve been able to be an assistant or head coach and played in the state championship in the last five years. Whether you’re winning or losing them, you realize it takes the same amount of work ethic, commitment and loyalty throughout the year just to get there.”

The Lady Vikings, who have won five state titles since 2010, won’t be short on talent as they pursue another one. 5-9 sophomore guard Kaitlyn Orihel avg. 10.5 ppg and was the only freshman to be named First Team All-Catholic last season. McDonald will also look to 5-9 senior guard Mia Andrews (Second Team All-Catholic), 5-8 senior guard Annie Whalen, who was a starter a year ago, and 5-6 senior point guard Ryleigh Parsons, who is “going to be who takes us the distance if we want to go to a championship especially in the Catholic League but also in states,” McDonald noted.
 


Archbishop Wood sophomore guard #4 Kaitlyn Orihel - PSD Photo


Archbishop Wood senior guard Mia Andrews - PSD Photo by Kathy Leister

A team that prevailed in a state title game was Andrea Peterson’s Neumann Goretti Saints. After a perfect PCL regular season, Neumann-Goretti (22-7, 12-0) stumbled in the league title game to O’Hara. Instead of faltering, all they did was win all five of their state tournament games by an avg. of 28.8 ppg en route to a fourth straight PIAA 3A title by defeating Bishop Canevin. They were led by PCL MVP and Class 3A Player of the Year Jabria Ingram, now at Hartford. She was the second straight league MVP from Neumann-Goretti joining Chyna Nixon (Temple). Also gone are Honorable Mention All-Catholic Daijah Parmley, Angel Ricks and Chelsea Keebler. 

2018 PIAA 3A Neumann-Goretti vs. Bishop Canevin Highlights:

Peterson, now in her 5th season, described separating the season into different parts, which has allowed her program have success over the course of the year. 

“We put three seasons together: our first season is our non-conference,” Peterson said. “The next season is the Catholic League and finally [the last season] is the state championship game. I always say we have three seasons in one. We always focus on the task at hand and never jump ahead. We focus on what we have to in order to get better.”

Expect the Saints to be in the mix for the league title as well as a fifth straight state title behind 5-11 senior forward Tatiana Jones, who avg. 14.0 ppg while being named First Team All-Catholic and Pa. All-State Class 3A Third Team, 5-6 sophomore guard Diamond Johnson, who scored 14 points in the state title game, and 5-7 senior guard Kiara Koger, who was a starter last year.

After another incredible season, Cardinal O’Hara (21-5, 10-2) will be going through a number of changes in the upcoming year. Former head coach Linus McGinty stepped down after winning 11 PCL titles in 24 years at the helm of the Lions and more than 800 games in 36 years as a head coach between Archbishop Carroll and O’Hara. In comes Chrissy Doogan, who was a two-time PCL MVP and had been an assistant under McGinty for the last five seasons. She takes over a team which has won two consecutive PCL crowns including last year’s 54-39 triumph over Neumann-Goretti. The Lions season came to an abrupt end as they lost in the opening round of PIAA 6A Tournament to eventual champion Upper Dublin, 42-35.

Gone are some of the most accomplished players in recent O’Hara history. Maura Hendrixson (Drexel), Mackenzie Gardler (Villanova), Hannah Nihill (Drexel), Mary Sheehan (St. Joe’s), Meghan Ricker (Immaculata), Emily Helms (Washington College) and Jasmin Miller (Pitt-Bradford) have all moved on. Hendrixson (13.8 ppg) and Gardler (14.2 ppg) were both First Team All-Catholic selections last season. Additionally, Gardler and Sheehan were 1,000-point scorers during their tenure.

Relive the excitement from the 2018 PCL Championship - O'Hara vs. Neumann-Goretti

There is still veteran leadership under Doogan as senior guard Kerry Patterson, a starter last season, and junior forward Stephanie Huseby, who started last year after transferring in from Shawnee (N.J.), return. They will be joined by senior guard Erin Welde and 5-10 sophomore forward Siobhan Boylan. 

According to Patterson, having had Doogan help build the program in recent years has been instrumental to her transition as head coach.

“She wants us to take it game by game,” Patterson said. “She doesn’t want us to look at the games in the future but rather focus on the little things that we need to work on so that when we do get back to the playoffs and the Palestra we’re not making the same mistakes we did back in December and January.”

Archbishop Carroll (21-8, 9-3) nearly took down Neumann-Goretti in the PCL semifinals but couldn’t close things out, losing 48-47. The Patriots, led by Molly Masciantonio, Wynter Bess, Kate Masciantonio, Kaitlyn Roccio and Alli Dreger, advanced to the PIAA 5A Tournament winning three games in the process before falling to eventual champ Mars, 52-39 in the semifinals. Masciantonio, a First Team All-Catholic and Pa. All-State Class 5A Second Team selection who avg. 16.1 ppg, finished as a 1,000-point scorer and is playing at Holy Family. 

Head coach Renie Shields raved about how the PCL’s depth made the run to the state semifinals possible in a lot of ways.

“The main thing is that every team comes ready to compete and the defensive efforts are always there,” Shields said. “Playing against tough defenses every night really raises the level of every player and then coaches try to strategize to beat those defenses.”

2018 PIAA 5A second round Carroll vs. Lower Dauphin Highlights

2018 PIAA 4A quarterfinal MBAP vs. Gwynedd Mercy - Highlight video by Geneva Heffernan

With the 2018 class gone, Shields will rely on junior forward Hope Syron and sophomore guard/forward Karli Dougherty, who was a starter last season but will be moved to sixth man this year to provide scoring off the bench.

Bonner-Prendergast (17-11, 8-4) had a strong run of their own in 2017-18. After losing to the Patriots in the PCL quarterfinals, 74-51, the Pandas grinded out three straight wins in the PIAA 4A Tournament by no more than eight points to reach the semifinals before falling to Lancaster Catholic. The entire roster is returning this season except for Second Team All-Catholic Nyah Garrison. Tom Stewart’s team will be led by 5-4 junior point guard Dakota McCaughan, a First Team All-Catholic who had 11 points, three rebounds, two assists, and a pair of steals in the state semifinal loss, and 5-10 junior forward Alexis Gleason, an Honorable Mention All-Catholic who had eight points and 11 rebounds in the state quarterfinals vs. Gwynedd Mercy Academy, and 5-10 senior forward Ariana McGeary, who posted a team-high 12 points off the bench against Lancaster Catholic.

It looked like early on last season as if Archbishop Ryan (17-6, 7-5) was in store for a magical season. They won a school-record 17 straight games to begin the year before succumbing down the stretch which culminated with a 59-36 loss to O’Hara in the league quarterfinals. The Ragdolls will be without two key members of last year’s squad in Second Team All-Catholic forward Caela Russell (Chestnut Hill College) and forward Danielle McCurdy (Scranton).


Archbishop Ryan senior #35 Monee Moore - PSD Photo by Kathy Leister

Mike McCuster, in his sixth season at the helm at Ryan, will have two-time First Team All Catholic and four-year starter Monee Moore (7.7 ppg) and 5-8 senior forward Shayne Glenn, last season’s sixth man, to help ease the inclusion of youth on this year’s team. Gabby Deluisi, a 5-7 junior guard who did not play varsity last season, will play meaningful minutes, and 5-4 freshman guard Tori Nigro will be one of seven freshmen on the roster.

McCuster understands inserting younger players into the rotation can sometimes shake their confidence but he feels the confidence of this freshmen class will only grow with experience.

“It’s a different atmosphere where you’re practicing pretty much every day and they’re much longer than what they’re used to,” McCuster said. “We try to fit them in with that situation at the beginning of the year. We’re pretty confident in the freshmen coming in and it might take some time to get adjusted but we’re hoping we build our nonleague schedule up to prepare them for the strong play of the Catholic League that they’ll be seeing.”


Give the Lady Crusaders a Follow on Instagram @lcladycrusaders - Photo courtesy of LC

Lansdale Catholic (16-8, 6-6) finished in fifth in the PCL regular-season standings and lost to Archbishop Wood, 63-33 in the league quarterfinals. Eric Gidney replaces Joe Mack and two accomplished players will need to be replaced. Brady Wassel (Holy Family) and Lauren Crim (Chestnut Hill College) were both Second Team All-Catholic selections. Crim became the first 1,000-point scorer for the Crusaders since 2011. 

Gidney will look to 5-8 senior forward Kristina Finkelston, who had nine points against Wood in PCL quarterfinals, 5-3 senior guard Maile Erwin, who scored 16 points vs. Pennridge on December 11, and 5-8 sophomore forward Timaya Lewis-Eutsey, who tallied 12 points in the Dec. 11 victory over the Rams.

Steve Prescott and Bishop McDevitt (7-11, 3-9) fell to the Crusaders, 51-40 in the first round of the PCL playoffs. They will have to replace Elan Wali and Second Team All-Catholic Nisea Burrell, who transferred to Westampton Tech (N.J.). Leading the way for the Lancers this season will be senior point guard Nyah Johnson, who had 10 points vs. Lansdale Catholic in league playoffs, and senior forward Dana Mizelle.

St. Hubert’s (8-14, 4-8) begins a new regime under Dave Schafer, who takes over for Katie Linder. Schafer previously was the head coach at Bishop Conwell from 1977-89 then the head coach at Bishop Egan from 1989-93 before the schools merged. He will have to replace Honorable Mention All-Catholic Megan O’Connell and guard Emma Keal (Gwynedd-Mercy). 

Schafer is looking to not only install a new system but a new culture into the Bambies program. 

“What we want to try to do is change the approach to the way the game is being played,” Schafer said. “We’re putting a lot of time in and working to develop the individual then as the individual develops the team will also. We’re emphasizing fundamentals all the time, especially on the defensive end. If we do all of the little things, everything else will come together.”

A few players who will be helping to lead the charge for Schafer will be 5-3 senior point guard Sarah Hartigan, 5-8 junior forward Cassidy Ruk, 5-8 sophomore forward Sarah Spaeth and 5-8 sophomore forward Payton Pugh.

Conwell-Egan (4-18, 2-10) begins its second season under Chris Brennan, a 1989 alum. The Eagles will be without Honorable Mention All-Catholic and team captain Alexis Mitchem (Bryn Athyn College) as well as Mary McKinney and Alexis Hyska, both also team captains a season ago. 5-5 junior guard Angel Crowell (sole captain), 5-8 junior forward Kylie Maroney (transfer from Pennsbury) and 5-10 junior forward Kaylee Seslar will be the core three this year.


Give the Lady Eagles a Follow on Instagram @cecgirlsbasketball - Photo courtesy of CEC

After going winless in 2015 and 2016, Brennan has the program headed in the right direction but he will need help finding players to provide leadership this season.

“We’re missing that leadership because on this particular team we don’t have any seniors,” Brennan said. “We have five juniors, four sophomores and four freshmen. We’re forcing juniors into a role that a few of them just aren’t ready for.” 

Maureen Buchter replaces Jenna Beck, who was the head coach the last two seasons, at Little Flower (4-13, 1-11). Buchter had coached the junior varsity team for the past 21 seasons. The team lost a wealth of seniors including Honorable Mention All-Catholic Nicolette Conway and Carly Huggard (Gwynedd-Mercy) in addition to Nicole Lemongelli, Celeste O’Neill and Ashley Zimmerman. Little Flower will have senior captain Alana Lacombe, junior forward Kelly Bauer, who Buchter coached at the JV level, and junior guard Amylynn Owen in its starting lineup this season.

Buchter, who played at Little Flower, has seen her fair share of PCL contests and recalls what a current Big 5 coach said about what it means to have been a member of this league.

“I can remember being invited to go to the Markward Club to bring a couple of our athletes,” Buchter said. “It was a man’s club but they had opened it up to women. As I sat there, the speaker happened to be Phil Martelli from St. Joe’s and the first thing he said, which rang so true, was how important it is when somebody meets you to say you were a part of the Philadelphia Catholic League. He said, ‘It doesn’t get any better than that.’”

John W. Hallahan (2-18, 0-12) will be under new direction as Mike Gallagher steps in for John Bernhardt, who is now the head coach at the Baldwin School. Gallagher will have some help getting acclimated to his new role with returning players in junior guard Samantha Burns (Honorable Mention All-Catholic) and senior forward Haydin Tomasweski, who is a four-year varsity player.

Gallagher knows there’s work to be done with his team but feels playing against the robust talent in the PCL will benefit his young team.

“We have teams at all different levels going to the state semifinals and championships,” Gallagher said. “Every year when you look at the bracket, we get a couple teams from each district and a bunch always make runs. It’s unlike any other league in the state.”

Last season was one of the best for the PCL in recent memory with six teams advancing to the state playoffs. It’s a league that challenges each team up and down the standings. The teams are constantly taking one another down and by the time the league playoffs come about it’s difficult to determine who has the upper hand. For McDonald, who is in his fourth season as head coach after two years as an assistant, the PCL is the class of PA.

“I’m a firm believer the Catholic League is one of, if not, the best basketball leagues in the entire country but definitely in the state,” McDonald said. “We have teams at all different levels going to state semifinals and championships. Every year when you look at the bracket, we get a couple teams from each district and a bunch always make runs. It’s unlike any other league in the state.”